Effect of replacing polyol by organosolv and kraft lignin on the property and structure of rigid polyurethane foam
© Pan and Saddler; licensee BioMed Central Ltd. 2013
Received: 2 October 2012
Accepted: 21 December 2012
Published: 28 January 2013
Lignin is one of the three major components in plant cell walls, and it can be isolated (dissolved) from the cell wall in pretreatment or chemical pulping. However, there is a lack of high-value applications for lignin, and the commonest proposal for lignin is power and steam generation through combustion. Organosolv ethanol process is one of the effective pretreatment methods for woody biomass for cellulosic ethanol production, and kraft process is a dominant chemical pulping method in paper industry. In the present research, the lignins from organosolv pretreatment and kraft pulping were evaluated to replace polyol for producing rigid polyurethane foams (RPFs).
Petroleum-based polyol was replaced with hardwood ethanol organosolv lignin (HEL) or hardwood kraft lignin (HKL) from 25% to 70% (molar percentage) in preparing rigid polyurethane foam. The prepared foams contained 12-36% (w/w) HEL or 9-28% (w/w) HKL. The density, compressive strength, and cellular structure of the prepared foams were investigated and compared. Chain extenders were used to improve the properties of the RPFs.
It was found that lignin was chemically crosslinked not just physically trapped in the rigid polyurethane foams. The lignin-containing foams had comparable structure and strength up to 25-30% (w/w) HEL or 19-23% (w/w) HKL addition. The results indicated that HEL performed much better in RPFs and could replace more polyol at the same strength than HKL because the former had a better miscibility with the polyol than the latter. Chain extender such as butanediol could improve the strength of lignin-containing RPFs.
KeywordsKraft lignin Lignin utilization Organosolv lignin Polyurethane Rigid foam
Polyurethane is one of the most important synthetic polymers, and it is synthesized through a polyaddition reaction between a polyisocyanate (a polymeric molecule with two or more isocyanate groups, such as toluene diisocyanate (TDI) and methylene diphenyl diisocyanate (MDI)) and a polyol (a polymer with two or more reactive hydroxyl groups, such as polyethylene adipate and poly(tetramethylene ether)glycol). Both the polyisocyanates and the polyols are currently derived from petroleum oil. Polyurethane has varied applications in different areas from liquid coatings and paints, tough elastomers, rigid foams for packing and insulation, to flexible foam in mattress and car seats .
Lignin is one of the three major components in plant cell walls and the most abundant aromatic polymer in the nature . Structurally, lignin is a 3-D networked polymer biosynthesized in plants from three monolignols, p-coumaryl alcohol, coniferyl alcohol, and sinapyl alcohol, through radical coupling processes . Lignin plays a vital function in the plant’s defense system against degrading enzymes and diseases. The lignin also binds fibers together to form a strong and tough matrix of plants and provides mechanical support to the plant vessels for the transportation of water and nutrients . However, the physical and chemical nature and functions of lignin make it troublesome in the utilization and conversion of lignocellulosic biomass. For example, lignin has to be removed (dissolved) during chemical pulping of wood to release/produce intact, strong, and bleachable fibers (pulp) for making paper. In bioconversion of lignocellulosic biomass to fuel ethanol, lignin is one of the major recalcitrance sources of the cellulosic substrates to cellulases. Furthermore, the lignin isolated from either chemical pulping or biorefining has not been utilized in a value-added way, and the most common lignin utilization is still steam and power production through combustion.
Extensive efforts have been made to explore high-value applications of lignin, in particular in polymeric materials, such phenolic and epoxy resins . Considering the fact that lignin is a polymer with a fair amount of hydroxyl (phenolic and aliphatic) and carboxylic groups that own reactive hydrogen, lignin has the potential to replace polyols in polyurethane production. For example, polyurethane film was prepared from organosolv lignin with polyethylene glycol as co-polyol and soft segments  with or without catalyst . Polyurethane foam was prepared from kraft lignin using polyethylene glycol as solvent . Water-soluble lignosulfonate from sulfite pulping was used to prepare rigid polyurethane foams in glycols . Lignin from straw steam explosion was also investigated for polyurethane preparation . A polyurethane elastomer (film) was prepared from flax soda lignin with polyethylene adipate and ethylene glycol as co-polyol and soft segment, but the resultant polyurethane film was heterogeneous and did not have adequate mechanical strength for any application when lignin content was over 10% (wt.) . Because of the solid state and less accessible hydroxyl groups of lignin, chemical modification such as oxypropylation with alkylene oxide was proposed to improve the accessibility of the hydroxyl groups, which could convert lignin into liquid polyol with extended chain and exposed hydroxyl groups [5, 12]. As a follow-up, recently, liquid polyol from oxypropylated pine kraft lignin was used to prepare rigid polyurethane foam . The same group also investigated the reinforcement of rigid polyurethane foam from oxypropylated ethanol organosolv lignin with cellulose nanowhiskers .
Organosolv ethanol process uses aqueous ethanol to extract lignin from lignocelluloses in the presence of small amount of inorganic acid as catalyst. It was developed in 1970s and commercialized in 1980s at pilot scale for producing pulp from hardwood for papermaking [15–17]. Recently, we reevaluated the organosolv process as a pretreatment method of woody biomass for cellulose ethanol production. It was found that the organosolv process was an effective pretreatment for both hardwood and softwood and the resultant cellulosic substrates had a ready digestibility with cellulases [18–21]. The isolated organosolv lignin during the pretreatment had attractive properties such as high purity, low molecular weight and narrow distribution, and more functional groups and the lignin was expected to have great potential in developing high-value lignin products [18, 22]. However, the products and market of organosolv lignin have not been sufficiently developed. It is believed that the successful commercialization of organosolv pretreatment is greatly dependent on whether the organosolv lignin can be utilized efficiently and in value-added ways, which is expected to offset the high cost of the organosolv process.
In the present research, hardwood ethanol organosolv lignin (HEL) was evaluated to replace synthesized polyol to prepare rigid polyurethane foam and compared with hardwood kraft lignin (HKL). The effect of lignin addition on foam preparation (viscosity of polyols) and foam properties (density, compressive strength, and cellular structure) was investigated. Chain extenders (glycerol and butanediol) were examined for improving the properties of the lignin-based polyurethane foams.
Results and discussion
Effect of replacement of polyol by lignin on the preparation of rigid polyurethane foam
Functional groups and molecular weight of the lignin samples
To verify whether the lignin was chemically crosslinked or just physically trapped in the polyurethane foam, the foam prepared with 25% (w/w) HEL was extracted with 90% dioxane (dioxane/water, v/v), a good solvent of HEL lignin. In the experiment, the foam was cut into small pieces of approximately 5 × 5 mm and extracted with the dioxane in a Soxhlet extractor for 24 hours to see the weight loss of the foam. Pure polyurethane foam without lignin was used as reference. It was found that the pure polyurethane foam lost approximately 3% of its original weight during the extraction, while the HEL-containing foam lost 7%. The results indicated that although more material was extracted from the lignin-containing foam, the majority of the lignin was not extractable, suggesting that the lignin be chemically cross-linked not physically trapped in the foam.
Effect of replacement of polyol by lignin on the density of polyurethane foam
Effect of replacement of polyol by lignin on the compressive strength of polyurethane foam
Replacing the polyol with 25% lignin reduced the compressive strength of the foam by 40%, compared to pure polyurethane foam without lignin, as shown in Figure 4, primarily because (1) the lignin was less reactive (hydroxyl groups in lignin was less accessible) than the polyol Voranol 270, and therefore the crosslinking density and strength of lignin-containing foam was lower than those of the pure PU foam; (2) the lignin was not completely miscible with the polyol, and thereby the lignin was not uniformly dispersed in the foam; and (3) the introduction of lignin reduced the uniformity of the foam cellular structure, and the deficiency in the cellular structure weakened the stability and strength of the structure.
Further increasing lignin content from 25% to 60% did not result in additional drop of the strength, but when lignin content was more than 60%, the compressive strength decreased again because too much lignin resulted in more irregular cellular structure and weakened the crosslinks, as shown in Figure 6.
Lignin content in rigid polyurethane foams
Ratio of lignin to polyol
HKL in PU foam, % (w/w)
HEL in PU foam, % (w/w)
Cellular structure of lignin-based polyurethane foam
As shown in Figure 6, cellular structure of the HEL-containing rigid polyurethane foams was observed under scanning electron microscope (SEM, images in the left column) and light microscope (images in the right column). Pure polyurethane foam without lignin had uniform cell size and regular cell shape, and it looked semitransparent with a light yellow color. With the introduction of HEL, the foam turned to the brown color of lignin. In addition, the shape of the cells became less regular, and large cells formed as well. It seemed that the effect of lignin on the cellular structure of the foams was insignificant when lignin replacement was less than 50%. However, when lignin ratio increased to 60% in particular to 70%, the foam cells became significantly irregular and many large cells (bubbles) formed. Furthermore, with the increased lignin content, lignin became poorly dispersed in the foam, and many large lignin granules were clearly visible under light microscope. The irregular cells, large bubbles, and poorly dispersed lignin were likely responsible for the low compressive strength of the foams at high lignin content, as discussed above. The cellular structures of HKL foams (images are not provided) were similar to those of HEL foams, but more irregular.
Effect of chain extenders on properties of lignin-containing polyurethane foam
Polyol was replaced with hardwood ethanol organosolv lignin (HEL) or hardwood kraft lignin (HKL) from 25% to 70% (molar percentage) in preparing rigid polyurethane foam (RPF). The prepared foams contained 12-36% (w/w) HEL or 9-28% (w/w) HKL. The density, compressive strength, and cellular structure of the foams were investigated and compared. It was found that the majority of the lignin was chemically crosslinked not just physically trapped in the foams as filler. The foams had satisfactory structure and strength up to 25-30% (w/w) HEL or 19-23% (w/w) HKL addition. The results indicated that HEL performed much better in RPFs and was able to give a better strength at the same lignin content or replace more polyol at the same strength than HKL presumably because the former had a better miscibility with the polyol than the latter. Addition of chain extender such as butanediol could improve the strength of lignin-containing RPFs.
Hardwood organosolv ethanol lignin (HEL) was generously provided by Lignol Innovation (Vancouver, Canada), produced from mixed hardwoods using the organosolv ethanol process . Hardwood kraft lignin (HKL) was generously contributed by Westvaco (Covington, VA), which was prepared from the black liquor of mixed hardwoods kraft pulping . Both lignins were spray-dried and had uniform and fine particle size, and HEL was slightly light in color (both brown) than HKL. The lignins were dried in a 105°C oven overnight before used in preparing polyurethane foam.
Characterization of the lignins
The functional groups of HEL and HKL were estimated using 1H NMR, and molecular weight was estimated using gel permeation chromatography (GPC). In brief, Functional groups (phenolic hydroxyl, aliphatic hydroxyl, and methoxyl groups) were determined using 1H-NMR. Lignin acetate (50 mg) and 5 mg of p-nitrobenzaldehyde (NBA, internal standard) were dissolved in 0.5 mL of deuterochloroform, and 1H-NMR spectra were recorded on a Bruker AV-300 spectrometer. The functional groups were estimated from the areas of their peaks, referring to the proton peak area of NBA . The number average and weight average molecular weights (Mn and Mw, respectively) of HEL and HKL were estimated by GPC using a Waters (Rochester, MN) HPLC system equipped with a Waters 717 autosampler, a Waters 2410 refractive index detector, and three Waters Styragel columns (HR5E, HR4, and HR2) in tandem. Lignin acetate (0.5 mg) was dissolved in 1 mL of tetrahydrofuran, and 30 μL of the solution were injected. The columns were calibrated with polystyrene standards .
Preparation of polyurethane foam from lignin
Where, WMDI, WL and WP = weights (g) of MDI, lignin and polyol, respectively; [NCO]MDI = molar content of isocyanate groups in MDI; [OH]L and [OH]P = molar content of total hydroxyl groups in the lignin and the polyol, respectively.
Viscosity of the mixture of the polyether polyol (Voranol 270) and lignin (HEL and HKL) was determined using a Brookfield dial reading rotary viscometer (Model LVT). The reported viscosity was the average of five measurements.
Characterization of polyurethane foams from lignin
Density of the foams was measured from the weight and volume of foam samples. Compressive strength was determined on an MTS Sintech 30/D material testing machine according to ASTM D-1621 (Standard test method for compressive properties of rigid cellular plastics). Light microscope images of the foams were taken on an Olympus BX51 microscope. SEM images of the foams were taken on a Hitachi S-2600N variable pressure scanning electron microscope.
XP is an Associate Professor of Bioenergy and Biomaterials. XP’s areas of interest include pretreatment and fractionation of lignocellulose, chemical and enzymatic saccharification of lignocellulose, biofuels (e.g. ethanol and hydrocarbon) from lignocellulose, and cellulose, hemicellulose and lignin based materials. JNS is a Professor of Forest Products Biotechnology. JNS’ research interests are application of enzymes in enhancing pulp and fiber properties, fiber modification and bleach boosting pulps, bioconversion of lignocellulosic residues to ethanol, microbiology of wastewater treatment, application of fungi to upgrading and modification of forest products, pulp and paper and waste streams.
Gel permeation chromatography
Hardwood ethanol organosolv lignin
Hardwood kraft lignin
High-Performance Liquid Chromatography
Methylene diphenyl diisocyanate
Number average molecular weight
Weight average molecular weights
Nuclear magnetic resonance
Rigid polyurethane foam
Scanning electron microscope
The authors acknowledge Tiffany Lu for her assistance in preparing foams and conducting density and compressive strength tests. We appreciate the constructive discussion on the present study with Dr. John Kadla. Thanks to George Lee for assistance with the compressive strength test of polyurethane foams.
- Szycher M: Szycher's Handbook of Polyurethanes. CRC Press LLC, Boca Raton; 1999.
- Rowell RM: Handbook of Wood Chemistry and Wood Composites. Taylor & Francis, Boac Raton; 2005.
- Lu F, Ralph J: Lignin. In Cereal Straw as a Resource for Sustainable Biomaterials and Biofuels. Edited by: Sun RC. Elsevier, Amsterdam; 2010:169-207.View Article
- Elumalai S, Pan XJ: Chemistry and Reactions of Forest Biomass in Biorefining. In Sustainable Production of Fuels, Chemicals, and Fibers from Forest Biomass. Edited by: Zhu JY, Zhang X, Pan XJ. American Chemical Society, Washington DC; 2011:109-144.View Article
- Lora JH, Glasser WG: Recent industrial applications of lignin: A sustainable alternative to nonrenewable materials. J Polyme Environ 2002, 10: 39-48. 10.1023/A:1021070006895View Article
- Thring RW, Ni P, Aharoni SM: Molecular weight effects of the soft segment on the ultimate properties of lignin-based polyurethanes. Int J Polym Mater 2004, 53: 507-524. 10.1080/00914030490267627View Article
- Ni P, Thring RW: Synthesis of polyurethanes from solvolysis lignin using a polymerization catalyst: mechanical and thermal properties. Int J Polym Mater 2003, 52: 685-707.View Article
- Hatakeyama H, Hatakeyama T: Lignin structure, properties, and applications. In Biopolymers, Lignin, Proteins, Bioactive Nanocomposites, Advances in Polymer Science 232. Edited by: Abe A, Ducek K, Kobayashi S. Springer, Berlin; 2010:1-63.
- Hatakeyama T, Matsumoto Y, Asano Y, Hatakeyama H: Glass transition of rigid polyurethane foams derived from sodium lignosulfonate mixed with diethylene, triethylene and polyethylene glycols. Thermochim Acta 2004, 416: 29-33. 10.1016/j.tca.2002.12.002View Article
- Bonini C, D'Auria M, Ernanuele L, Ferri R, Pucciariello R, Sabia AR: Polyurethanes and polyesters from lignin. J Appl Polym Sci 2005, 98: 1451-1456. 10.1002/app.22277View Article
- Ciobanu C, Ungureanu M, Ignat L, Ungureanu D, Popa VI: Properties of lignin-polyurethane films prepared by casting method. Ind Crops Prod 2004, 20: 231-241. 10.1016/j.indcrop.2004.04.024View Article
- Cateto CA, Barreiro MF, Rodrigues AE, Belgacem MN: Optimization study of lignin oxypropylation in view of the preparation of polyurethane rigid foams. Ind Eng Chem Res 2009, 48: 2583-2589. 10.1021/ie801251rView Article
- Li Y, Ragauskas AJ: Kraft lignin-based rigid polyurethane foam. J Wood Chem Technol 2012, 32: 210-224. 10.1080/02773813.2011.652795View Article
- Li Y, Ragauskas AJ: Ethanol organosolv lignin-based rigid polyurethane foam reinforced with cellulose nanowhiskers. RSC Advances 2012, 2: 3347-3351. 10.1039/c2ra00646dView Article
- Williamson PN: Repas Alcell process - new demonstration facility shows how pulp mills can be cheaper. Sven Papperstidn 1988, 91: 21-23.
- Pye EK, Lora JH: The Alcell process - a proven alternative to kraft pulping. Tappi J 1991, 74: 113-118.
- Stockburger P: An overview of near-commercial solvent-based pulping processes. Tappi J 1993, 76: 71-74.
- Pan XJ, Arato C, Gilkes N, Gregg D, Mabee W, Pye EK, Xiao ZZ, Zhang X, Saddler J: Biorefining of softwoods using ethanol organosolv pulping: Preliminary evaluation of process streams for manufacture of fuel-grade ethanol and co-products. Biotechnol Bioeng 2005, 90: 473-481. 10.1002/bit.20453View Article
- Pan XJ, Gilkes N, Kadla J, Pye EK, Saka S, Gregg D, Ehara K, Xie D, Lam D, Saddler J: Bioconversion of hybrid poplar to ethanol and co-products using an organosolv fractionation process: Optimization of process yields. Biotechnol Bioeng 2006, 94: 851-861. 10.1002/bit.20905View Article
- Pan XJ, Xie D, Yu RW, Lam D, Saddler JN: Pretreatment of lodgepole pine killed by mountain pine beetle using the ethanol organosolv process: Fractionation and process optimization. Ind Eng Chem Res 2007, 46: 2609-2617. 10.1021/ie061576lView Article
- Pan XJ, Xie D, Yu RW, Saddler JN: The bioconversion of mountain pine beetle-killed lodgepole pine to fuel ethanol using the organosolv process. Biotechnol Bioeng 2008, 101: 39-48. 10.1002/bit.21883View Article
- Pan XJ, Kadla J, Ehara K, Gilkes N, Saddler J: Organosolv ethanol lignin from hybrid poplar as a radical scavenger: Relationship between lignin structure, extraction conditions, and antioxidant activity. J Agric Food Chem 2006, 54: 5806-5813. 10.1021/jf0605392View Article
- Lora JH, Goyal GC, Raskin M: Characterization of residual lignins after Alcell pulping. Procedings of the 7th International Symposium on Wood and Pulping Chemistry: 25–28 May 1993: Beijing 1993, 327-336.
- Kadla JF, Kubo S: Miscibility and hydrogen bonding in blends of poly(ethylene oxide) and kraft lignin. Macromolecules 2003, 36: 7803-7811. 10.1021/ma0348371View Article
- Pan XJ, Sano Y: Atmospheric acetic acid pulping of rice straw IV: Physico-chemical characterization of acetic acid lignins from rice straw and woods. part 2. Chemical structures. Holzforschung 1999, 53: 590-596.
This article is published under license to BioMed Central Ltd. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/2.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.