Skip to main content

Table 1 Bacterial population diversity at early, mid, and late fermentation stages in nine different commercial ethanol plants

From: Bacteriophage application restores ethanol fermentation characteristics disrupted by Lactobacillus fermentum

Plant

Fermentation stage (hours)

Bacteria level (CFU/g)

# of total OTU

# of LAB OTU

Lactobacillus (%)

Streptococcus (%)

Lactococcus (%)

Weissella (%)

Enterococcus (%)

Pediococcus (%)

Total LAB (%)a

1

11

NA

68

7

36.10

     

36.10

24

NA

98

12

91.91

0.02

  

0.01

 

91.94

52

NA

21

6

91.09

0.78

    

91.87

2

25

4.4E+07

16

10

5.78

0.51

0.65

92.22

0.07

 

99.23

34

1.9E+07

15

10

3.62

0.61

0.47

79.50

 

0.10

84.30

43

9.4E+06

15

12

16.09

9.98

3.42

70.10

  

99.59

3

15

8.6E+04

30

21

4.53

0.18

63.08

30.34

0.02

 

98.15

30

3.6E+04

19

10

47.36

0.35

0.35

39.58

  

87.64

45

1.7E+04

24

9

16.54

 

0.44

75.51

  

92.49

4

9

1.6E+07

55

15

7.32

4.93

0.66

11.86

  

24.77

27

1.8E+06

19

13

54.70

25.07

0.33

18.47

  

98.57

45

7.8E+04

17

11

82.66

8.92

1.48

5.85

  

98.91

5

18

1.2E+07

11

8

40.64

 

58.42

0.64

0.07

 

99.77

32

1.8E+06

18

9

75.00

 

23.51

0.06

  

98.57

45

8.6E+05

14

5

70.55

 

2.47

 

25.60

 

98.62

6

8

5.6E+05

18

17

28.56

69.03

  

0.75

 

98.34

26

2.5E+05

26

18

81.77

8.84

  

5.11

0.41

96.13

34

1.0E+07

12

11

93.71

6.18

    

99.89

7

15

4.4E+03

25

7

13.15

4.21

46.31

 

0.52

3.16

67.35

34

2.8E+05

41

9

39.46

5.54

5.54

   

50.54

42

2.8E+04

18

6

17.61

1.14

68.47

   

87.22

8

17

2.2E+06

7

7

2.31

97.54

    

99.85

35

7.8E+05

8

5

67.46

22.81

  

9.20

 

99.47

54

7.0E+03

14

9

38.86

23.45

  

36.40

 

98.71

9

6

3.0E+05

23

8

14.20

  

0.71

 

41.84

56.75

24

2.5E+05

19

7

26.94

0.52

   

54.92

82.38

49

3.0E+04

32

6

29.34

    

14.97

44.31

  1. Values less than 0.01 % or not detected are not shown
  2. OTU operational taxonomic units, NA data not available
  3. a% of LAB is calculated as the sum at Lactobacillales order level