One-step production of C6–C8 carboxylates by mixed culture solely grown on CO
Biotechnology for Biofuels volume 11, Article number: 4 (2018)
This study aimed at producing C6–C8 medium-chain carboxylates (MCCAs) directly from gaseous CO using mixed culture. The yield and C2–C8 product composition were investigated when CO was continuously fed with gradually increasing partial pressure.
The maximal concentrations of n-caproate, n-heptylate, and n-caprylate were 1.892, 1.635, and 1.033 mmol L−1, which were achieved at the maximal production rates of 0.276, 0.442, and 0.112 mmol L−1 day−1, respectively. Microbial analysis revealed that long-term acclimation and high CO partial pressure were important to establish a CO-tolerant and CO-utilizing chain-elongating microbiome, rich in Acinetobacter, Alcaligenes, and Rhodobacteraceae and capable of forming MCCAs solely from CO.
These results demonstrated that carboxylate and syngas platform could be integrated in a shared growth vessel, and could be a promising one-step technique to convert gaseous syngas to preferable liquid biochemicals, thereby avoiding the necessity to coordinate syngas fermentation to short-chain carboxylates and short-to-medium-chain elongation. Thus, this method could provide an alternative solution for the utilization of waste-derived syngas and expand the resource of promising biofuels.
In recent times, conversion of waste to biochemicals has been a highlighted topic in the context of biorefinery industry. Products of anaerobic fermentation from waste, i.e. short-chain carboxylic acids (SCCAs) and alcohols, can be converted to more valuable medium-chain carboxylic acids (MCCAs), such as n-caproate and n-caprylate, by mixed culture (also called “open culture” or “reactor microbiomes”) under anaerobic conditions, and this reaction is known as chain elongation [1, 2]. Acetate and ethanol are the dominant products derived from syngas anaerobic fermentation, while syngas, a mixture of CO, H2, and CO2, is sustainably produced from the thermal treatment of biowaste or artificial polymers [3,4,5]. Therefore, it is reasonable to integrate the two bioprocesses (i.e. chain elongation and syngas fermentation) to achieve the conversion of gaseous syngas to preferable liquid biochemicals, which could provide an alternative solution for the utilization of waste-derived syngas and expand the resource of promising biofuels. Thermal treatment serves as a depolymerization pretreatment of complex waste to produce syngas (carbon source and electron donor) for anaerobic conversion into clean and easily separable biochemicals.
In a previous study, Kucek et al.  successfully achieved MCCAs production by mixed culture from a synthetic substrate of ethanol and acetate, which mimicked syngas fermentation products. Similarly, Vasudevan et al.  obtained n-caproic acid using mixed culture from real syngas fermentation effluent. Furthermore, Gildemyn et al.  converted real syngas fermentation effluent into MCCAs in continuous fermentation using pure culture of Clostridium kluyveri, which is one of the known model organisms for chain elongation.
Nevertheless, direct production of liquid MCCAs from syngas or the dominant component—gaseous CO is much preferable, because the process requires only one bioreactor for control and optimization. To date, only some studies have achieved this one-step production process with the combination of two pure cultures on a bench scale. For example, Diender et al.  accomplished MCCAs production from CO using co-culture of Clostridium autoethanogenum and C. kluyveri, which are the model organisms for syngas metabolism and chain elongation, respectively. Richter et al.  used co-culture of carboxydotrophic Clostridium ljungdahlii and chain-elongating C. kluyveri to produce MCCAs and corresponding alcohols. Perez et al.  converted carboxylic acids to their corresponding alcohols using syngas as electron donor by carboxydotrophic bacteria C. ljungdahlii and C. ragsdalei. However, pure cultures are inclined to be sensitive to environmental disturbance and susceptible to contamination, and hence, are not perfect for industrial application with regard to waste valorization [12, 13]. Esquivel-Elizondo et al. . gained MCCAs production from combination of ethanol and CO, where CO was used to inhibit the methanogenesis and was regarded to contribute as potential electron donor at partial pressure between 0.11 and 0.3 atm. Zhang et al.  got MCCAs production from mixture of CO2 and H2 by mixed culture, which also belongs to syngas components. However, compared to easily bio-converted CO2 and H2, CO is the most toxic and becomes the limitation for the utilization of syngas by mixed culture.
Therefore, the present study aimed at producing MCCAs using mixed culture using solely gaseous CO both as carbon source and electron donor. One-step production utilizing CO at gradient partial pressures was continuously run long term for 199 days. Subsequently, the production performance and microbial community composition corresponding to the combined operation of CO fermentation and chain elongation were investigated.
Reactor setup and cultivation
The reactor (Fig. 1) was made of polymethyl methacrylate, had a total volume of 21 L and effective volume of 18 L, and was purged with high-purity nitrogen gas (99.999%) to guarantee anaerobic condition. The reactor was filled with non-biodegradable, erosion-resistant sponge scouring pad, which was made of polyester fiber. The size of the fillers was about 1 cm × 1 cm × 0.5 cm, with average porosity of 96.8 ± 0.2%, average aperture of 20.12 μm, and specific surface area of 0.2063 m2 g−1. The inoculum was derived from anaerobic granular sludge of a mesophilic biogas reactor treating paper mill wastewater. The granular sludge was crushed and sieved through a 500-μm screen. The inoculum of 20 g L−1 volatile solids (VS) was added.
The reactor was operated in a semi-continuous mode, with continuous supply of gaseous CO and retention of liquid products. The CO served as the single carbon source and electron donor, and the partial pressure of CO in the 7-L gas bag containing the mixture of CO and N2 was gradually increased considering the toxicity of the gas to the mixed culture. Periodic gas circulation in upflow mode at a frequency of 15 min h−1 and flow rate of 300 mL min−1 was applied through a peristaltic pump to enhance mass transfer from gas to liquid. The gas bag was emptied and then refilled with CO–N2 mixture every 2 days. The basic culture medium was the same as that reported in previous studies [16, 17], except for the addition of 0.5 g L−1 yeast extract in the present study. The pH of the medium was only initially adjusted to 7.12 by adding 4 M HCl, and was not controlled afterwards. The mixed culture was incubated under mesophilic condition at constant temperature (35 °C) and 50 mmol L−1 2-bromoethanesulfonate (2-BES) was added to it to inhibit methanogenesis .
Based on the gradually increased partial pressure of the supplied CO, the experiment (run for 199 days) was divided into seven phases: I (0–12 days, CO = ~0.15 atm), II (13–22 days, CO = ~0.25 atm), III (23–34 days, CO = ~0.35 atm), IV (35–46 days, CO = ~0.40 atm), V (47–60 days, CO = ~0.50 atm), VI (61–100 days, CO = ~0.60 atm), and VII (101–199 days, CO = ~0.60 atm). Phase VII was set when the MCCAs production occurred from about 100th day.
Every 2 days before gas renewal, the components and volume of the gas in the gas bag were tested. The components of the gas (O2, H2, CH4, CO, CO2) were measured using a gas chromatograph (Trace1300, Thermo Fisher Scientific, Waltham, MA, USA) equipped with a flame ionization detector and thermal conductivity detector. The volume of the gas was determined by a gas meter (TG05/6, Ritter, Bochum, Germany).
Liquid samples were taken every 2 days and their pH and oxidation–reduction potential (ORP) were determined using a pH meter (PXSJ-216F, Shanghai Precision and Scientific Instrument Co., LTD, Shanghai, China) and an automatic potentiometric titrator (ZD-2, Shanghai Precision and Scientific Instrument Co., LTD, Shanghai, China), respectively. Subsequently, the samples were centrifuged at 4460g for 10 min in a high-speed refrigerated centrifuge (TL-18 M, Shanghai Centrifugal Machinery Research Institute, Shanghai, China), and the supernatant was diluted and acidified with 3% (v/v) phosphoric acid for carboxylates (C2–C8) analysis and just diluted for DOC, DIC and DN analysis. The concentration of carboxylates (C2–C8) was defined as the total amount of undissociated and dissociated forms of carboxylates, and was measured using a gas chromatograph (Focus GC, Thermo Scientific Co., Waltham, MA, USA) equipped with a flame ionization detector and 30 m × 0.25 mm DB-WAX UI polyethylene glycol capillary column. The dissolved organic carbon (DOC), dissolved inorganic carbon (DIC), and dissolved nitrogen (DN) contents were determined using a total carbon/total nitrogen analyzer (TOC-VCPN, TNM-1, Shimadzu, Kyoto, Japan). The CO consumption in moles was calculated by Clapeyron–Clausius equation: PV = nRT (T = 308 K). The carbon conversion efficiencies were calculated as weighted averages based on the input carbon (gaseous CO) and the carbon content of the products (mmol L−1).
For microbial analysis, 10 samples were periodically collected on days 0, 10 (phase I), 20 (phase II), 34 (phase III), 44 (phase IV), 56 (phase V), 74 (phase VI), 100 (phase VI), 130 (phase VII), and 155 (phase VII), and stored at − 80 °C. The total DNA in each sample was extracted using a PowerSoil® DNA isolation kit (Mo-Bio Laboratories Inc., Carlsbad, CA, USA) following manufacturer’s instructions. The quality of the DNA was assessed using gel electrophoresis (1% agarose), and the DNA concentrations were determined by NanoDrop 2000 spectrophotometer (Thermo Scientific Co., Waltham, MA, USA) (see Additional file 1: Table S1).
The variable regions V4–V5 of the microbial 16S ribosomal RNA gene were amplified by PCR using the primers ArBa515F (5′–GTGCCAGCMGCCGCGGTAA–3′) and Arch806R (5′–GGACTACHVGGGTWTCTAAT–3′), which were selected as the sequencing primers set to simultaneously obtain bacterial and archaeal information. The high-throughput sequencing was performed using Illumina HiSeq2500 platform by Majorbio Bio-pharm Technology Co., Ltd, Shanghai, China. The pretreatment and sequencing procedure were performed as described by Amato et al. . The bioinformatic analyses were conducted on the online i-sanger sever (http://www.i-sanger.com/) of Majorbio Bio-pharm Technology Co., Ltd. Principle component analysis (PCA) based on Bray–Curtis distance for total microbiomes, bacteria, and archaea were conducted by the software PAST (V. 3.1.0).
Results and discussion
The reactor performance indicated by cumulative CO consumption, cumulative biogas production, DOC, DIC, DN, pH, and ORP is shown in Fig. 2. During all the seven phases, a total of 16,025 mmol CO was consumed, while only 170 mmol H2, 56 mmol CO2, and 337 mmol CH4 were produced as biogas (Fig. 2b). Therefore, the carbon loss during conversion into biogas was negligible and only contributed to 2.4%. Nevertheless, dissolved CO2 or carbonate was significantly produced in phases I and II, reaching up to 172 mg L−1, and then gradually decreased (Fig. 2c). In contrast, DOC content progressively increased from 1262 to 3903 mg L−1 (Fig. 2c), whereas pH decreased from 7.12 to 6.31, indicating the conversion of CO into liquid organics (Fig. 2e), which was probably the cause of the pH drop. Furthermore, DN content sharply decreased in phase I from 528 to 355 mg L−1, implying active cell proliferation, and then slowly increased to 580 mg L−1 (Fig. 2d). The concentration profiles of the produced carboxylates (acetate, propionate, i-butyrate, n-butyrate, i-valerate, n-valerate, n-caproate, n-heptylate, and n-caprylate) during the operation period are shown in Fig. 3.
Production of MCCAs (up to C8) from gaseous CO by mixed culture
Although previous studies have attempted to integrate syngas fermentation and chain elongation, the present study is the first to achieve n-caprylate production directly from gaseous CO by mixed culture. The maximal n-caprylate concentration was 1.033 mmol L−1, with the highest production rate of 0.112 mmol L−1 day−1 (Table 1). In addition, maximal n-caproate concentration of 1.892 mmol L−1 was also noted, with the highest production rate of 0.276 mmol L−1 day−1. The other even-carbon-number carboxylates produced included acetate (80.649 mmol L−1) and n-butyrate (8.121 mmol L−1). Nonetheless, it must be noted that the MCCAs production rates and maximal concentrations obtained in the present study are not higher than those reported in previous works using pure cultures and/or syngas fermentation effluent (Table 2), which may be owing to insufficient substrate and toxicity of the carboxylate products. First, acetate is essential for MCCAs production because it is the initial feedstock of reversed β-oxidation, which is considered as the model reaction of chain elongation [20, 21]. Furthermore, Diender et al.  observed that addition of acetate significantly stimulated MCCAs production from CO. In contrast, in the present study, low-carbon-density gaseous CO was used as the solo substrate, which resulted in relatively low concentration of acetate in the liquid broth. Nevertheless, the MCCA concentrations and production rates obtained in the present study are comparable with those reported by Zhang et al. , who achieved conversion of gaseous CO2 and H2 to MCCAs without addition of acetate. Second, product toxicity has been generally recognized by researchers, and various extraction methods such as membrane extraction and electrolytic extraction have been developed [22,23,24]. In the present study, obvious product inhibition was observed during phase VII of operation, when n-caproate and n-caprylate production was almost stopped and the product concentrations remained unaltered (Fig. 3a).
It must be noted that the production of n-caproate and n-caprylate occurred at the end of phase VI of operation, with the highest concentrations obtained at the beginning of phase VII, indicating a lag phase of 96 and 100 days, respectively. Similarly, Richter et al.  reported a lag phase of 700 h for n-caproate production in a total operation period of 2200 h, while Zhang et al.  observed a lag phase of 37 and 65 days for n-caproate and n-caprylate production, respectively, in a total operation period of 80 days. These findings indicate that lag phases are quite common and that the elongation sequentially progresses to carboxylates of higher carbon number.
Production of odd-carbon-number carboxylates
Chain elongation is achieved via the cyclic process of reversed β-oxidation, during which the carboxylates are elongated by two carbon atoms in every cycle [2, 25]. The reversed pathway could accept both even- and odd-chain substrates for carbon chain initiation and elongation [2, 25]. As most of the studies on chain elongation have employed acetate as the substrate and ethanol as the electron donor, only even-carbon-number carboxylates have been mainly discussed [24, 26,27,28]. Nevertheless, odd-carbon-number carboxylates, such as propionate, n-valerate, and n-heptanoate, have also been detected in these systems in small quantities with low proportions of production (propionate: 0–17.6 mmol L−1, 0–2%; n-valerate: 0–8.8 mmol L−1, 0–5%; n-heptanoate: 0–3.8 mmol L−1, 0–7%) [24, 26,27,28]. Liu et al. documented that hydrolysis of protein-rich biowaste produced propionate, which could be further elongated . Furthermore, Grootscholten et al. . successfully produced n-valerate and n-heptanoate from propionate by using ethanol as the electron donor. In the present study, propionate was synthesized continuously during the operation period (Fig. 3b), and the maximal propionate concentration obtained was 4.424 mmol L−1, with the highest production rate of 0.617 mmol L−1 day−1 (Table 1). While inoculum hydrolysis might contribute to a part of propionate production , the rest of the propionate produced might have been directly derived from CO fermentation, because comparable propionate production from syngas fermentation has been reported in a previous study by Liu et al. .
Furthermore, n-valerate (1.669 mmol L−1) and n-heptylate (1.635 mmol L−1) were also produced almost synchronously with n-caproate and n-caprylate during phase VII of operation, suggesting that lag phase also existed for n-valerate and n-heptanoate production. While a negligible increase in the concentration of i-butyrate from 1.573 to 2.042 mmol L−1 was observed during phase I–IV, the concentration remained almost unchanged, suggesting that i-butyrate was probably not the product of chain elongation (Fig. 3c). Furthermore, i-valerate was absent during phase I, but suddenly increased to 0.926 mmol L−1 at the beginning of phase II, and slowly reached 1.919 mmol L−1 on day 199 (Fig. 3c).
Increase in CO partial pressure promoted CO utilization and product selectivity
The reactor performance varied during the seven phases of operation owing to different CO partial pressures. The average rates of CO consumption increased from phase I to VI with the increase in CO partial pressure (Table 2). Phases I–VII could be regarded as the period of gradual acclimation of the mixed culture to utilize CO as the substrate, and the toxicity of CO to the microorganisms could be alleviated by the presence of carboxydotrophic organisms . However, the average CO utilization rate of phase VII decreased despite the supplementation of the same concentration of CO as that in phase VI (Table 1), which could possibly be owing to product inhibition.
Theoretically, production of methane was not expected because 2-BES was added to totally inhibit methanogenesis . However, methane production was noted in phase VI and its concentration rapidly increased (Fig. 2a), suggesting that the inhibitor lost its efficacy to some extent during long-term operation. It has been reported that 2-BES could be consumed as a competing electron acceptor by sulfate-reducing bacteria or dehalogenating microorganisms in mixed culture [30, 31]. In the present study, hydrogen synthesis started from phase II and continued during phases III, IV, and V (Fig. 2a), whereas CO2 was produced in small quantity during phases I, II, and III and sharply increased during phases IV and V (Fig. 2a). Some of the CO2 produced might have contributed to the increase in DIC content during phases I and II as dissolved CO2 or carbonate/bicarbonate. In phase III, the DIC content decreased with the decline in pH (Fig. 2d, e). During phase VI, both H2 and CO2 produced were re-consumed by the mixed culture, which could also be used as substrate for MCCAs production .
Figure 4 shows the compositions of the produced carboxylates as well as the DIC, CO2, and CH4 contents in the initial culture and at the end of each operation phases, calculated based on mmol C. To estimate the carbon source provided by the dead cell decompose and yeast extract, cell elemental composition of C5H7NO2 and the data of DN (Fig. 2d) were used. The DN increases from 528 to 580 mg L−1, corresponding to a carbon increment of 18.6 mmol L−1. This is negligible (2.1%) compared with carbon increment of 890.3 mmol L−1 of CO consumption, Therefore, the following calculation ignored the carbon contribution from inoculum. While DIC, acetate, propionate, i-butyrate, and n-butyrate were detected in the initial culture, acetate was the dominant product, reaching 42.1% (day 0). The increase in CO partial pressure obviously broadened the products spectrum and also improved product selectivity. The selectivity of undesired products, such as i-butyrate, declined from 27.2% (day 0) to 3.5% (day 199). Furthermore, the proportion of DIC decreased from 22.4% (day 0) to 2.3% (day 199), whereas that of acetate remained at around 50%, with increasing absolute concentration (Fig. 3a). A similar phenomenon was also observed for propionate, with generally unchanged selectivity but increased absolute concentration (Fig. 3b). The selectivity of n-butyrate increased from 3.6% (day 0) to 11.7% (day 199), along with an increase in its absolute concentration. It must be noted that n-caproate, n-heptylate, and n-caprylate were first synthesized during phase VI, and exhibited selectivity of 3.9, 4.1, and 2.9%, respectively.
Dominant microorganisms in the mixed culture
A total of 366,264 sequences with an average length of 273 bp were obtained from the 10 samples. The sequences were characterized and used for taxonomic classification against Silva database (Release128, http://www.arb-silva.de), and the taxonomic distribution of all the microbiomes at genus level is shown in Fig. 5. The genera with average relative abundance of more than 1% are listed in Additional file 1: Table S2. Overall, Methanosaeta (16.2% ± 9.4%), Methanobacterium (14.0 ± 3.7%), Acinetobacter (5.9 ± 5.5%), Alcaligenes (5.7 ± 6.4%), Dechlorobacter (4.5 ± 9.1%), and OTU (operational taxonomic units) from Rhodobacteraceae (4.3 ± 5.4%) were dominant at the genus level among the 10 samples.
To determine the response of the microbial structure to gradient partial pressures of CO, the 10 samples were subjected to principle component analysis (PCA) based on Bray–Curtis distance for total microbiomes, bacteria, and archaea (Fig. 6). The first two principal coordinates showed 69.8, 65.0, and 99.6% of the total variation, respectively. Based on the distribution distance, the results indicated that microbial diversity and community structure were closely related to CO concentration, especially with regard to the structure of bacteria. The close distance between samples collected on day 130 and 155 indicated establishment of a stable microbial community during the long-term operation period with CO as the sole substrate. Furthermore, sample collected on day 20 was distant from other samples, indicating distinctions in microbial community structures, which resulted from the outburst of Dechlorobacter in sample collected on day 20. Dechlorobacter, which is closest to the genus Azospira, is a (per)chlorate-reducing β-proteobacterium . Thus, in the present study, a novel strain isolated from paper mill waste might have possibly existed in the mixed culture and might belong to the genus Dechlorobacter, which can use acetate, propionate, and butyrate as electron donors and chlorate as electron acceptor . These chlorate-reducing microorganisms in the mixed culture could use 2-BES as electron acceptor because the tetrahedral structure of 2-BES with three oxygen bonds is similar to chlorate. In a previous study by Steinbusch et al. , Dechlorosoma oryzae, which could also use 2-BES as methanogenesis inhibitor, was found to be dominant in the chain-elongating mixed culture.
As expected, the relative abundance of the major methanogens Methanosaeta and Methanobacterium decreased from 36.6 to 8.0% and from 16.1 to 8.6% in all the microbiomes with increasing acclimation time, respectively, because methanogenesis was inhibited by 2-BES. Furthermore, the proportion of archaea in the microbiomes declined from 60.1 to 20.2%, while their composition remained almost unchanged (Fig. 5b). Thus, archaea in the mixed culture had an insignificant relationship with CO consumption or MCCAs production, which was further confirmed by the relative decentralized distribution of the samples in PCA of archaea (Fig. 6c).
Microorganisms responsible for MCCAs production from CO
The microorganisms exhibiting an increase in abundance along with the incubation period could be effectively responsible for MCCAs production from CO. To exclude background interference from the initial inoculum, PCA based on the ratio of relative abundance of microorganisms was performed and the results were compared with those of the initial inoculum culture (Fig. 7). Alcaligenes, Acinetobacter, OTU from Rhodobacteraceae, Clostridium, Desulfitobacterium, and OTU from Bacilli, Saccharibacteria, and Coriobacteriaceae were identified to be responsible for MCCAs production from CO because they were closely abundant in the samples from phases VI and VII.
Interestingly, the relative abundance of Acinetobacter, Alcaligenes, and OTU from Rhodobacteraceae significantly increased (Figs. 5a, 6a, b, 7), which was unexpected based on previous reports on syngas fermentation and chain elongation. Acinetobacter calcoaceticus, the dominate species of the genus Acinetobacter, which accounted for more than 49.1% of the sequences from Acinetobacter in the present study, is known to produce fatty alcohols and acids. This bacterium possesses the gene encoding fatty acyl-CoA reductases, which play significant role in reversed β-oxidation pathway for MCCAs production [34, 35]. Furthermore, the wax ester synthase/acyl-CoA: diacylglycerol acyltransferase of Acinetobacter baylyi catalyzes the esterification of ethanol with acyl-CoA [34, 35]. It has been reported that Acinetobacter strains could grow on CO, and produce carbon monoxide dehydrogenase (CODH), the key enzyme that catalyzes CO conversion . Therefore, Acinetobacter could be one of the microorganisms that could simultaneously utilize CO and participate in chain elongation. Kucek et al.  also found OTUs for Acinetobacter spp. that were predominant and increased in dominance up to 55.5% of the relative abundance of their chain elongation works.
Among Alcaligenes spp., including A. aquatilis, A. faecalis, and A. eutrophus, A. eutrophus is well known for its ability to synthesize poly-β-hydroxybutyrate. Furthermore, A. eutrophus could synthesize polyhydroxyalkanoates under the conditions of growth inhibition by CO , and the Ni–Fe hydrogenase of A. eutrophus is tolerant to CO . Moreover, the CODH gene has also been observed in the genome of A. faecalis and A. eutrophus (http://www.uniprot.org). It has been reported that the genes that are crucial for MCCAs production, such as β-ketothiolase and NADPH-linked acetoacetyl-CoA reductases, are abundant and actively expressed in A. eutrophus [39,40,41], and that genes encoding long-chain acyl-CoA synthetase are abundant in Alcaligenes genomes (http://www.uniprot.org).
Rhodobacteraceae is mainly found in marine environment, and nearly all of its members harbor the CODH gene, indicating their ability to oxidize CO [39,40,41]. Thus, the OTU from Rhodobacteraceae detected in the present study may also contribute to CO utilization. A previous study reported that Rhodobacteraceae possesses genes required for the biosynthesis of indole 3-acetic acid , and that members of this family could produce secondary metabolites such as phenylacetic acid and tropodithietic acid . However, these microorganisms have been rarely reported in chain elongation studies, and the enzymes required for reversed β-oxidation, such as fatty acyl-CoA synthase and long-chain acyl-CoA synthetase, have all been discovered in the genomes of Rhodobacteraceae (http://www.uniprot.org).
The sample collected on day 100 (phase VII) was important because n-valerate, n-caproate, n-heptylate, and n-caprylate were all produced at a high rate around this period (Fig. 3a, b). Clostridium spp. were observed in small quantity (< 0.2%) during phases I–IV, and increased up to 3.6% on day 100 (see Additional file 1: Table S2). It is known that Clostridium spp. are associated with carboxylates metabolism, and C. kluyveri has been the most studied and considered as the model microorganism for chain elongation by reversed β-oxidation [20, 21]. However, the relative abundance of Clostridium spp. in the present study was quite low, when compared with those reported by Zhang et al.  (47.6% of C. ljungdahlii, C. autoethanogenum, and C. kluyveri), Algar et al.  (50% of C. ljungdahlii and C. kluyveri), and Steinbusch et al.  (57.8% of C. kluyveri). Nonetheless, although the abundance of Clostridium spp. was not as high as expected, the increase in the relative abundance of Clostridium spp. was positively correlated with MCCAs production. Some members of Clostridium spp., such as C. ljungdahlii and C. autoethanogenum, are known to be syngas utilizer. C. autoethanogenum is one of the model organisms for syngas metabolism and can convert CO or syngas to ethanol and acetate , while C. ljungdahlii is also known as a typical carboxydotrophic bacterium . In the present study, the sequences from Clostridium spp. were assigned to C. kluyveri, C. ljungdahlii, and C. autoethanogenum, which might have played a significant role in CO utilization as well as chain elongation in the mixed culture. Based on the results of microbial analysis, it can be concluded that Acinetobacter, Alcaligenes, and OTU from Rhodobacteraceae could harbor the potential for both CO utilization and chain elongation, and could achieve MCCAs production from CO as the sole substrate, besides Clostridium spp. that are well known for their ability of CO utilization and chain elongation.
In the present study, the feasibility of one-step C6–C8 MCCAs production from CO as the sole substrate without additional electron donors was confirmed. Although fermentation of CO into C2–C4 SCCAs was not difficult and could be directly initiated with an anaerobic biogas-producing microbiome, the process required long acclimation period of up to 100 days to obtain a microbiome capable of directly converting CO to C6–C8 MCCAs. In the first five phases of operation, acetate and butyrate production reached 50 and 6 mmol L−1, respectively, and no n-caproate, n-heptylate, or n-caprylate was detected. It must be noted that a similar inoculum was used in our previous study to initiate chain elongation of acetate and ethanol in not more than 20 days . Therefore, it can be concluded that the shortage of CO-utilizing chain-elongating microorganisms, and not the lack of SCCAs-utilizing chain-elongating microorganisms or inadequate SCCAs as substrate, resulted in the absence of C6–C8 acids. In the first 90 days, 64% of the produced acids were acetate and the rest were C3–C5 products. In contrast, during 90–199 days, n-caproate, n-heptylate, and n-caprylate contributed to 13, 14, and 10% of the newly produced acids, respectively, when compared with acetate (45%) and n-butyrate (13%), confirming that phase VII operation was established with CO-tolerant and CO-utilizing chain-elongating microbiomes.
Overall, the present study is a proof-of-principle that the carboxylate and syngas platform could be integrated in a shared growth vessel, and could become a promising method to convert syngas to preferable liquid biochemicals, which is significant as a new starting point for value-added exploitation of syngas. Although further studies are needed before its practical application, including improvement of production yield and selectivity, improvement of gas–liquid mass transfer, control of products formation, onsite products separation and purification technologies, etc., the concept of one-step MCCAs production from CO could evoke a new window for syngas biorefinery and necessitate coordinating the cooperation of syngas fermenters and chain elongators. Moreover, one-step MCCAs production from CO can be realized in a single cell, and the biorefinery potentials of the speculated CO-utilizing chain-elongating microorganisms, such as Alcaligenes, Acinetobacter, and OTU from Rhodobacteraceae, in addition to Clostridium spp., need to be further exploited.
Agler MT, Spirito CM, Usack JG, Werner JJ, Angenent LT. Chain elongation with reactor microbiomes: upgrading dilute ethanol to medium-chain carboxylates. Energy Environ Sci. 2012;5(8):8189–92.
Spirito CM, Richter H, Rabaey K, Stams AJ, Angenent LT. Chain elongation in anaerobic reactor microbiomes to recover resources from waste. Curr Opin Biotechnol. 2014;27:115–22.
Devarapalli M, Atiyeh HK, Phillips JR, Lewis RS, Huhnke RL. Ethanol production during semi-continuous syngas fermentation in a trickle bed reactor using Clostridium ragsdalei. Bioresour Technol. 2016;209:56–65.
Richter H, Molitor B, Wei H, Chen W, Aristilde L, Angenent LT. Ethanol production in syngas-fermenting Clostridium ljungdahlii is controlled by thermodynamics rather than by enzyme expression. Energy Environ Sci. 2016;9(7):2392–9.
Liu K, Atiyeh HK, Stevenson BS, Tanner RS, Wilkins MR, Huhnke RL. Continuous syngas fermentation for the production of ethanol, n-propanol and n-butanol. Bioresour Technol. 2014;151:69–77.
Kucek LA, Spirito CM, Angenent LT. High n-caprylate productivities and specificities from dilute ethanol and acetate: chain elongation with microbiomes to upgrade products from syngas fermentation. Energy Environ Sci. 2016;9(11):3482–94.
Vasudevan D, Richter H, Angenent LT. Upgrading dilute ethanol from syngas fermentation to n-caproate with reactor microbiomes. Bioresour Technol. 2014;151:378–82.
Gildemyn S, Molitor B, Usack JG, Mytien N, Rabaey K, Angenent LT. Upgrading syngas fermentation effluent using Clostridium kluyveri in a continuous fermentation. Biotechnol Biofuels. 2017;10(83):975.
Diender M, Stams AJ, Sousa DZ. Production of medium-chain fatty acids and higher alcohols by a synthetic co-culture grown on carbon monoxide or syngas. Biotechnol Biofuels. 2016;9(82):82.
Richter H, Molitor B, Diender M, Sousa DZ, Angenent LT. A narrow pH range supports butanol, hexanol, and octanol production from syngas in a continuous co-culture of Clostridium ljungdahlii and Clostridium kluyveri with in-line product extraction. Front Microbiol. 2016;7:1773.
Perez JM, Richter H, Loftus SE, Angenent LT. Biocatalytic reduction of short-chain carboxylic acids into their corresponding alcohols with syngas fermentation. Biotechnol Bioeng. 2013;110(4):1066–77.
Kleerebezem R, van Loosdrecht MC. Mixed culture biotechnology for bioenergy production. Curr Opin Biotechnol. 2007;18(3):207–12.
Esquivel-Elizondo S, Delgado AG, Rittmann BE, Krajmalnik-Brown R. The effects of CO2 and H2 on CO metabolism by pure and mixed microbial cultures. Biotechnol Biofuels. 2017;10(1):220.
Esquivel-Elizondo S, Miceli J, Torres CI, Krajmalnik-Brown R. Impact of carbon monoxide partial pressures on methanogenesis and medium chain fatty acids production during ethanol fermentation. Biotechnol Bioeng. 2017. https://doi.org/10.1002/bit.26471.
Zhang F, Ding J, Zhang Y, Chen M, Ding ZW, van Loosdrecht MC, Zeng RJ. Fatty acids production from hydrogen and carbon dioxide by mixed culture in the membrane biofilm reactor. Water Res. 2013;47(16):6122–9.
Liu Y, He P, Shao L, Zhang H, Lu F. Significant enhancement by biochar of caproate production via chain elongation. Water Res. 2017;119:150–9.
Liu Y, Lu F, Shao L, He P. Alcohol-to-acid ratio and substrate concentration affect product structure in chain elongation reactions initiated by unacclimatized inoculum. Bioresour Technol. 2016;218:1140–50.
Zinder SH, Anguish T, Cardwell SC. Selective-inhibition by 2-bromoethanesulfonate of methanogenesis from acetate in a thermophilic anaerobic digester. Appl Environ Microbiol. 1984;47(6):1343–5.
Amato KR, Yeoman CJ, Kent A, Righini N, Carbonero F, Estrada A, Gaskins HR, Stumpf RM, Yildirim S, Torralba M, et al. Habitat degradation impacts black howler monkey (Alouatta pigra) gastrointestinal microbiomes. ISME J. 2013;7(7):1344–53.
Seedorf H, Fricke WF, Veith B, Bruggemann H, Liesegang H, Strittmatter A, Miethke M, Buckel W, Hinderberger J, Li F, et al. The genome of Clostridium kluyveri, a strict anaerobe with unique metabolic features. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2008;105(6):2128–33.
Barker HA, Kamen MD, Bornstein BT. The synthesis of butyric and caproic acids from ethanol and acetic acid by Clostridium kluyveri. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 1945;31(12):373–81.
Andersen SJ, Candry P, Basadre T, Khor WC, Roume H, Hernandez-Sanabria E, Coma M, Rabaey K. Electrolytic extraction drives volatile fatty acid chain elongation through lactic acid and replaces chemical pH control in thin stillage fermentation. Biotechnol Biofuels. 2015;8(221):1972.
Xu J, Guzman JJL, Andersen SJ, Rabaey K, Angenent LT. In-line and selective phase separation of medium-chain carboxylic acids using membrane electrolysis. Chem Commun. 2015;51(31):6847–50.
Ge S, Usack JG, Spirito CM, Angenent LT. Long-term n-caproic acid production from yeast-fermentation beer in an anaerobic bioreactor with continuous product extraction. Environ Sci Technol. 2015;49(13):8012–21.
Angenent LT, Richter H, Buckel W, Spirito CM, Steinbusch KJ, Plugge CM, Strik DP, Grootscholten TI, Buisman CJ, Hamelers HV. Chain elongation with reactor microbiomes: open-culture biotechnology to produce biochemicals. Environ Sci Technol. 2016;50(6):2796–810.
Grootscholten TIM, Steinbusch KJJ, Hamelers HVM, Buisman CJN. High rate heptanoate production from propionate and ethanol using chain elongation. Bioresour Technol. 2013;136:715–8.
Grootscholten TIM, Strik DPBT, Steinbusch KJJ, Buisman CJN, Hamelers HVM. Two-stage medium chain fatty acid (MCFA) production from municipal solid waste and ethanol. Appl Energy. 2014;116:223–9.
Steinbusch KJJ, Hamelers HVM, Plugge CM, Buisman CJN. Biological formation of caproate and caprylate from acetate: fuel and chemical production from low grade biomass. Energy Environ Sci. 2011;4(1):216–24.
Liu K, Atiyeh HK, Stevenson BS, Tanner RS, Wilkins MR, Huhnke RL. Mixed culture syngas fermentation and conversion of carboxylic acids into alcohols. Bioresour Technol. 2014;152:337–46.
Chiu PC, Lee M. 2-Bromoethanesulfonate affects bacteria in a trichloroethene-dechlorinating culture. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2001;67(5):2371–4.
Ye D, Quensen JF 3rd, Tiedje JM, Boyd SA. 2-Bromoethanesulfonate, sulfate, molybdate, and ethanesulfonate inhibit anaerobic dechlorination of polychlorobiphenyls by pasteurized microorganisms. Appl Environ Microbiol. 1999;65(1):327–9.
Thrash JC, Pollock J, Torok T, Coates JD. Description of the novel perchlorate-reducing bacteria Dechlorobacter hydrogenophilus gen. nov., sp. nov. and Propionivibrio militaris, sp. nov. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol. 2010;86(1):335–43.
Bruce RA, Achenbach LA, Coates JD. Reduction of (per)chlorate by a novel organism isolated from paper mill waste. Environ Microbiol. 1999;1(4):319–29.
Reiser S, Somerville C. Isolation of mutants of Acinetobacter calcoaceticus deficient in wax ester synthesis and complementation of one mutation with a gene encoding a fatty acyl coenzyme A reductase. J Bacteriol. 1997;179(9):2969–75.
Steen EJ, Kang Y, Bokinsky G, Hu Z, Schirmer A, McClure A, Del Cardayre SB, Keasling JD. Microbial production of fatty-acid-derived fuels and chemicals from plant biomass. Nature. 2010;463(7280):559–62.
Cho JW, Yim HS, Kim YM. Acinetobacter isolates growing with carbon monoxide. Kor J Microbiol. 1985;23(1):1–8.
Volova TG, Kalacheva GS, Altukhova OV. The autotrophic synthesis of polyhydroxyalkanoate by Alcaligenes eutrophusin the presence of carbon monoxide. Microbiology. 2001;70(6):640–6.
Schneider K, Cammack R, Schlegel HG, Hall DO. Iron-sulfur centers of soluble hydrogenase from Alcaligenes eutrophus. Biochim Biophys Acta. 1979;578(2):445–61.
Haywood GW, Anderson AJ, Chu L, Dawes EA. The role of NADH-linked and NADPH-linked acetoacetyl-CoA reductases in the poly-3-hydroxybutyrate synthesizing organism Alcaligenes eutrophus. FEMS Microbiol Lett. 1988;52(3):259–64.
Schubert P, Steinbuchel A, Schlegel HG. Cloning of the Alcaligenes eutrophus genes for synthesis of poly-beta-hydroxybutyric acid (PHB) and synthesis of PHB in Escherichia coli. J Bacteriol. 1988;170(12):5837–47.
Valentin HE, Steinbuchel A. Application of enzymatically synthesized short-chain-length hydroxy fatty-acid coenzyme A thioesters for assay of polyhydroxyalkanoic acid synthases. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol. 1994;40(5):699–709.
Simon M, Scheuner C, Meier-Kolthoff JP, Brinkhoff T, Wagner-Dobler I, Ulbrich M, Klenk HP, Schomburg D, Petersen J, Goker M. Phylogenomics of Rhodobacteraceae reveals evolutionary adaptation to marine and non-marine habitats. ISME J. 2017;11(6):1483–99.
Seyedsayamdost MR, Case RJ, Kolter R, Clardy J. The Jekyll-and-Hyde chemistry of Phaeobacter gallaeciensis. Nat Chem. 2011;3(4):331–5.
Abrini J, Naveau H, Nyns E-J. Clostridium autoethanogenum, sp. nov., an anaerobic bacterium that produces ethanol from carbon monoxide. Arch Microbiol. 1994;161(4):345–51.
Koepke M, Held C, Hujer S, Liesegang H, Wiezer A, Wollherr A, Ehrenreich A, Liebl W, Gottschalk G, Duerre P. Clostridium ljungdahlii represents a microbial production platform based on syngas. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA. 2010;107(29):13087–92.
The manuscript was written through contributions of all authors. All authors have given approval to the final version of the manuscript. All authors contributed equally to this study. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
All data generated or analysed during this study are included in this published article and its supplementary information files.
Consent for publication
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The authors would like to acknowledge the support from National Natural Science Foundation of China (51622809, 51378375), Fundamental Research Funds for Central Universities (0400219341), the Collaborative Innovation Center for Regional Environmental Quality.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
He, P., Han, W., Shao, L. et al. One-step production of C6–C8 carboxylates by mixed culture solely grown on CO. Biotechnol Biofuels 11, 4 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13068-017-1005-8
- Syngas fermentation
- Chain elongation
- One-step production
- Mixed culture