Research | Open | Published:
Combining loss of function of FOLYLPOLYGLUTAMATE SYNTHETASE1 and CAFFEOYL-COA 3-O-METHYLTRANSFERASE1 for lignin reduction and improved saccharification efficiency in Arabidopsis thaliana
Biotechnology for Biofuelsvolume 12, Article number: 108 (2019)
Downregulation of genes involved in lignin biosynthesis and related biochemical pathways has been used as a strategy to improve biofuel production. Plant C1 metabolism provides the methyl units used for the methylation reactions carried out by two methyltransferases in the lignin biosynthetic pathway: caffeic acid 3-O-methyltransferase (COMT) and caffeoyl-CoA 3-O-methyltransferase (CCoAOMT). Mutations in these genes resulted in lower lignin levels and altered lignin compositions. Reduced lignin levels can also be achieved by mutations in the C1 pathway gene, folylpolyglutamate synthetase1 (FPGS1), in both monocotyledons and dicotyledons, indicating a link between the C1 and lignin biosynthetic pathways. To test if lignin content can be further reduced by combining genetic mutations in C1 metabolism and the lignin biosynthetic pathway, fpgs1ccoaomt1 double mutants were generated and functionally characterized.
Double fpgs1ccoaomt1 mutants had lower thioacidolysis lignin monomer yield and acetyl bromide lignin content than the ccoaomt1 or fpgs1 mutants and the plants themselves displayed no obvious long-term negative growth phenotypes. Moreover, extracts from the double mutants had dramatically improved enzymatic polysaccharide hydrolysis efficiencies than the single mutants: 15.1% and 20.7% higher than ccoaomt1 and fpgs1, respectively. The reduced lignin and improved sugar release of fpgs1ccoaomt1 was coupled with changes in cell-wall composition, metabolite profiles, and changes in expression of genes involved in cell-wall and lignin biosynthesis.
Our observations demonstrate that additional reduction in lignin content and improved sugar release can be achieved by simultaneous downregulation of a gene in the C1 (FPGS1) and lignin biosynthetic (CCOAOMT) pathways. These improvements in sugar accessibility were achieved without introducing unwanted long-term plant growth and developmental defects.
Lignocellulosic biomass is viewed as a desirable sustainable feedstock for the production of biofuels because of its abundance and renewable nature [1,2,3,4]. Lignin, a major component of lignocellulose, cross-links with hemicellulose in the cell wall to form the lignin–hemicellulose matrix [5,6,7,8]. The lignin and hemicellulose matrix encrusts the cellulose skeleton, providing mechanical support for the growing plant. Moreover, the lignocellulose complex forms a barrier allowing unimpeded substrate transport protecting plants against pathogens, which are critical for plant growth, development, and survival [9, 10]. The amount and composition of lignin differs among species and individual tissues, as well as in tissues under different plant growth conditions or developmental stages. To produce biofuel from lignocellulosic biomass, polysaccharides must be separated or loosened from the lignocellulose matrix for hydrolyzation into sugar subunits and fermentation into ethanol. However, the presence of lignin reduces hydrolyzation rates (e.g., saccharification efficiency) by limiting enzyme access to the polysaccharides. The reduction of lignin content or modification of its structure is important not only for biofuel applications, but also for improving the digestibility of some plants for animal consumption [11,12,13,14,15,16].
Lignin biosynthesis consists of three steps: the synthesis of lignin monolignols, their transport to the lignifying sites, and the polymerization of monolignols into the growing lignin polymer . Monolignol biosynthesis starts with the amino acid, l-phenylalanine, and proceeds through the general phenylpropanoid pathway [13, 17,18,19,20]. There are three basic types of monomer units: the p-hydroxyphenyl (H), guaiacyl (G), and syringyl (S) units. Besides hydroxylation, the major difference between the three lignin monomers is the degree of methylation on the aromatic ring. In plants, there are two O-methyltransferases in the lignin biosynthesis pathway, namely, caffeoyl coenzyme A 3-O-methyltransferase (CCoAOMT) and caffeoyl-CoA 3-O-methyltransferase (COMT). COMT is responsible for the O-methylation at the C5 position of the phenolic ring while CCoAOMT’s function is in the O-methylation of the C3 position [21, 22]. However, there are reports that COMT is also involved in the O-methylation at the C3 position [22, 23].
CCoAOMT was first implicated in lignin production during studies showing the differentiation of tracheary elements in cultured Zinnia mesophyll cells . It is now well understood that CCoAOMT is the key methylation enzyme for caffeoyl-CoA, producing feruloyl-CoA, an upstream component of the G and S monolignol branches [22, 25, 26]. Mutation or transgenic downregulation of CCoAOMT genes causes changes in lignin content and composition in a number of plant species such as tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) [25,26,27], woody poplar (Populus tremula x Populus alba) [21, 28], alfalfa (Medicago sativa) [29,30,31], flax (Linum usitatissimum) , pine (Pinus radiata) , maize (Zea mays) , and thale cress (Arabidopsis thaliana) [22, 35]. There are seven putative CCoAOMTs in the Arabidopsis genome , with CCoAOMT1 [At4g34050] confirmed to be the primary family member involved in the monolignol pathway .
In plants, synthesis of major end products such as lignin, phytohormones, betaines, and alkaloids requires methylation reactions [37,38,39]. The required methyl groups are donated by the universal methyl group donor S-adenosylmethionine (AdoMet), and they originate from the C1 derivatives of the cofactor tetrahydrofolate. Lignin accumulation in plants was thus predictably affected by mutations in genes responsible for producing AdoMet, or in genes responsible for maintaining pools of the folate C1 derivatives. Mutation of S-adenosylmethionine synthetase3 (SAMS3), whose protein product catalyzes synthesis of AdoMet from l-methionine and ATP, leads to over-accumulation of methionine and a significant decrease in total lignin content in Arabidopsis . Folates play a central role in C1 metabolism by providing one-carbon groups for methylation reactions in living organisms. In maize, the brown-midrib (bm) natural mutants, bm2 and bm4, are disrupted in genes encoding a methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase (MTHFR)  and a folylpolyglutamate synthase (FPGS) , respectively. Reductions in lignin content and altered lignin composition were observed in both bm mutants [41, 42]. We recently reported that mutation of FPGS1 by T-DNA insertions in Arabidopsis resulted in lower lignin content and reduced cell-wall recalcitrance .
One method to improve plants for biofuel production while maintaining their normal growth is to alter the expression of multiple genes in the lignin biosynthesis pathway as opposed to one. Three double-mutant combinations of peroxidase (Prx) among AtPrx2, AtPrx25, and AtPrx71 in Arabidopsis had near normal growth phenotypes with reduced lignin contents . Similarly, Arabidopsis double mutants in which the expression of transaldolase (TRA2), cinnamate 4-hydroxylase (C4H), or 4-coumarate:CoA ligase (4CL1) with a COMT gene were simultaneously reduced, resulted in higher saccharification efficiency without compromising plant biomass yield . Transgenic tobacco plants in which cinnamyl alcohol dehydrogenase (CAD) and cinnamoyl CoA reductases (CCR) were simultaneously downregulated, also had reduced lignin and normal growth . However, some double mutants or transgenetically altered plants targeting two genes for downregulation, such as Arabidopsis ccoaomt1 comt1 and switchgrass hydroxycinnamoyl CoA:shikimate hydroxycinnamoyl transferase (HCT) 1 and 2, have compromised growth [22, 47], suggesting that not all mutant combinations of genes in lignin biosynthesis present practical strategies for overcoming recalcitrance. One further modification that has succeeded in returning plant growth to normal was to downregulate or overexpress other lignin-related genes or transcription factors [48,49,50]. Such elaborate experimental approaches to modify lignin content enable the plants with reduced lignin content not only for practical biofuel-based applications but also as tools for gaining a deeper understanding of regulatory mechanisms underlying lignin biosynthesis.
To explore other possibilities for lignin reduction through multiple gene downregulations and to further understand the interaction of lignin biosynthesis with the C1 metabolic pathway, double mutants between fpgs1 and ccoaomt1 were generated in Arabidopsis, and their growth phenotype and cell-wall biochemistry/recalcitrance were studied. Our results show that simultaneous downregulation of a lignin biosynthetic gene and a C1 metabolic gene alters lignin composition and increases sugar release in Arabidopsis without long-term adverse growth impacts.
Expression patterns of CCoAOMT1 and FPGS1 in Arabidopsis stems
In corn, FPGS and CCoAOMT are important for lignin production, as shown by the reduced lignin content observed for plants mutated or downregulated for FPGS  or CCoAOMT expression . FPGS1 and CCoAOMT1 are highly expressed in lignified Arabidopsis stems [22, 43]. To study their interactions in relation to lignin biosynthesis, the expression profiles of CCoAOMT1 and the FPGS gene family were examined under the same growth conditions. The samples used for transcript level analysis included root and shoot tissues from 2-week-old Arabidopsis (col-0) plants as well as leaf, flower, and stem tissues from 6-week-old Arabidopsis (col-0) plants. Quantitative RT-PCR results showed that the across-all-tissues expression levels of CCoAOMT1 was higher than the expression levels of the FPGS gene family. The high transcript level of CCoAOMT1 in the stems, especially in the top portion of 6-week-old stem where lignification is occurring, demonstrates the correlation between CCoAOMT1 activity and lignification (Fig. 1). Among members of the FPGS gene family, FPGS1 had a relatively high expression level in different portions of the stem and flower tissues of 6-week-old plants (Fig. 1). FPGS2 and FPGS3 had relatively high expression levels in shoots of 2-week-old plants and flowers of 6-week-old plants (Fig. 1). The expression level of FPGS1 is the highest among three gene family members in the stem, indicating that it is the best isoform to study interactions between C1 and lignin biosynthesis pathways in Arabidopsis stems.
Generation and characterization of single and double mutants
The fpgs1 Arabidopsis mutant used in this study was the fpgs1-1 line . The DNA sequence in the region of FPGS1 in the specific homozygous fpgs1 plant used to cross with the ccoaomt1 mutant was confirmed by PCR using genotyping primers (Additional file 1: Table S1). The T-DNA insertion was confirmed to be in the fifth intron of gene FPGS1 (Fig. 2a) as previously described . The homozygous fpgs1 plants did not show obvious growth defects compared to the wild type except for the short root phenotype in the seedling stage (Additional file 2: Fig. S1).
The DNA sequence in the region of the homozygous ccoaomt1 plant used to cross with the fpgs1 plant was determined by PCR using genotyping primers and coincided with the sequence determined for SALK_151507 (Additional file 1: Table S1). There were two contiguous T-DNAs inserted in tandem in the fourth exon of the CCoAOMT1 gene (Fig. 2a). The homozygous ccoaomt1 plants, similar to the ccoaomt1-3 line previously reported , had no significant growth defects under our growth conditions.
The homozygous fpgs1 (♀) and ccoaomt1 (♂) Arabidopsis mutants were crossed to generate F1 plants whose F2 plants would segregate. Homozygous single and double mutants were obtained from the F2 population and confirmed by PCR using genotyping primers (Additional file 1: Table S1). We also investigated FPGS1 and CCOAOMT1 expressions in single and double homozygous mutants. The RT-PCR results showed that expression level of both genes were beyond detection in corresponding single and double homozygous mutants 9 days after germination (Fig. 2b).
The growth and development of single and double homozygous mutants were examined. Under long-day conditions, aerial growth of the double-mutant fpgs1ccoaomt1, was visually similar to the single mutants and wild type (WT) 6 weeks post germination (Fig. 2c). Aerial phenotypic traits, including plant height, fresh weight of aboveground plant material, and stem material, were compared between WT, single, and double mutants from 6-week-old plants (Fig. 2d). The results showed that the measured growth traits for the double-mutant fpgs1ccoaomt1 were comparable to WT and each of the single mutants except for root length at early stages of growth, in which it was shorter than WT and ccoaomt1 but similar to the fpgs1 mutant (Additional file 2: Fig. S1).
Impact of FPGS1 and CCoAOMT1 disruption on lignin content and composition in the fpgs1ccoaomt1 mutant
GC-coupled thioacidolysis was used to measure the relative content of lignin monomers bound by β-O-4 linkages  in the stems of 6-week-old double-mutant fpgs1ccoaomt1, single mutants fpgs1 and ccoaomt1, and WT plant tissue. When monomer subunits were totaled, stems from the single mutants, fpgs1 and ccoaomt1, and the double-mutant, fpgs1ccoaomt1, showed decreases, respectively, of 18.7%, 25.2%, and 26.7%, compared with WT stems (Fig. 3a). Relative content for each monomer was calculated from thioacidolysis-derived lignin monomers for each genotype (Fig. 3b). When compared with WT stems, the fpgs1 stems had slight reduction of G- and S- monomers but had a significant 3.6-fold increase of H- monomers (Fig. 3b). The ccoaomt1 stems had a 21% reduction of G-monomers and a 54% increase of S-monomers while had a slight increase (7%) of H-monomers (Fig. 3b). The double-mutant stems had a 20% reduction of G-monomers while a 49% increase of S-monomers and a significant 3.6-fold increase of H-monomers (Fig. 3b). Based on thioacidolysis, there was no change of S/G ratio in fpgs1 tissue compared with WT tissue. On the contrary, there were very significant increases in S/G ratios in both the double mutant and ccoaomt1 compared with WT plants (Fig. 3c). The higher S/G ratio in Arabidopsis ccoaomt1 mutants was also reported in other studies [22, 35]. Based on two-dimensional (2D) 1H–13C heteronuclear single-quantum coherence (HSQC) NMR, fpgs1 tissue had relatively more H units than WT tissue, similar to what was observed by thioacidolysis, while maintaining the same S/G ratio as WT tissue (Additional file 3: Table S2). Similar to what was measured by thioacidolysis, ccoaomt1 and fpgs1ccoaomt1 showed decrease of relative content of G units, and relative increase of S and H units; the S/G ratios in ccoaomt1 and fpgs1ccoaomt1 were significantly increased compared with WT tissue (Additional file 3: Table S2).
Total lignin content in stems of 6-week-old plants was also determined by the acetyl bromide (AcBr) method , which, unlike thioacidolysis, is independent of linkage composition. The single mutants fpgs1 and ccoaomt1 had 20% and 32.5% reductions of AcBr lignin, respectively, compared with the WT plants (Fig. 3d). The double mutant had a 37.2% reduction of AcBr lignin compared with the WT plants (Fig. 3d), indicating a further reduction of lignin content in fpgs1ccoaomt1 compared with each of the single mutants. A 17% reduction in AcBr lignin content was also observed previously in the single Arabidopsis mutant fpgs1 . Reduced AcBr lignin content and an increase of the S/G ratio in ccoaomt1 mutants were also reported in earlier work in Arabidopsis [22, 35].
In addition to total monomer yield, the linkage pattern affects the property of lignins, e.g., the percentage of β-O-4-ether bonds can closely reflect the degree of condensation of the lignin polymer in the samples and potentially affect plant recalcitrance . 2D HSQC-NMR was also used to analyze the relative abundance of lignin interunit linkages. The distribution patterns of the main interunit linkages in fpgs1 were similar to those in the wild type. Both ccoaomt1 and fpgs1ccoaomt1 showed slightly higher proportions of β-O-4 linkages, and lower numbers of β-5 linkages than WT-fpgs1 (Additional file 3: Table S2). These results indicated that the distribution of interunit linkages and lignin composition in the double-mutant fpgs1ccoaomt1 were more similar to those in ccoaomt1 than to fpgs1. Furthermore, two functional groups, the acetyl and the methoxyl, were measured by NMR analysis. All mutants had higher levels of acetyl groups than in the WT controls, and there was no difference among the mutants. Similar levels of methoxyl groups were observed for all three mutants and WT control (Additional file 3: Table S2).
Saccharification yield and enzymatic hydrolysis efficiency is increased in the fpgs1ccoaomt1 mutant
Total sugar and enzymatically released sugar were determined for the stems of 6-week-old double-mutant, fpgs1ccoaomt1, each single-mutant, and wild-type Arabidopsis plants through the phenol–sulfuric acid method (PSA) . Based on PSA, total sugar release from destarched alcohol-insoluble residue (AIR) without acid pretreatment was 10.5%, 14.2%, and 16.9% more in the fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and fpgs1ccoaomt1 extracts, respectively, compared with WT extracts (Table 1).
Enzymatically released sugar from destarched AIR, without acid pretreatment, was 11.5%, 18.5%, and 38.7% more in fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and the double mutant than WT stems, respectively (Table 1). When compared to each single mutant, the double mutant had 24.4% and 17.0% higher enzymatically released sugar than fpgs1 and ccoaomt1 extracts, respectively (Table 1). Subsequently, the enzymatic hydrolysis efficiency was calculated as the percentage of enzymatic sugar release yield to the total sugar release yield . When compared to WT, fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and the double-mutant extracts showed a 5.0%, 10.5%, and 27.2% increase in enzymatic hydrolysis efficiency, respectively (Table 1). When compared to each single mutant, the double mutant had a 20.7% increase versus the fpgs1 value and a 15.1% increase versus the ccoaomt1 value, for its enzymatic hydrolysis efficiency (Table 1).
Overall the simultaneous disruption of FPGS1 and CCOAOMT1 expression in plants increased the total sugar release, enzymatic sugar release, and enzymatic hydrolysis efficiency compared with disruption of each gene alone.
Glycome profiling reveals major differences in non-cellulosic cell-wall components between mutant and WT plants
The AIR materials from 6-week-old stems for all four genotypes, WT, fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and the double mutant, were used for glycome profiling. Glycome profiles can show the extractability of various non-cellulosic cell-wall components, i.e., xyloglucan, xylan, and pectin/arabinogalactan epitopes, through six sequential extractions under increasingly harsh conditions. When considering total non-cellulosic carbohydrate released from AIR during each of the extractions, there were more carbohydrates extracted from mutants at moderate harshness. For example, under 1 M KOH condition, there were more carbohydrates recovered for all three mutants; there were a noticeable increase in the amount of total carbohydrates extracted for double mutants in 4 M KOH. The extractability of non-cellulosic carbohydrate reversed in the two most harsh conditions, with the mutants having less non-cellulosic carbohydrates recovered while the wild type had more. For example, the double mutant had the least recovered carbohydrates under Chlorite extraction condition while the wild type had the most under the Post Chlorite 4 M KOH extract condition, among all four genotypes (Fig. 4). These results indicated that the extractability of non-cellulosic carbohydrates from all mutants’ cell wall was higher than those from wild-type cell walls. Most noticeable is the highest extractability of non-cellulosic carbohydrates from cell wall of double-mutant fpgs1ccoaomt1 (Fig. 4).
When equal amount of carbohydrates extracts for each extract was loaded for epitope detection, the glycome-profiling results showed high resemblance of each mutant to those of wild-type lines. A limited number of carbohydrates differed between the mutants when each was compared against WT. Only very few epitopes show significant difference among the genotypes. When comparing glycome-profiling data of each single mutant against that of the double mutant, the difference between fpgs1 and ccoamt1 was minor but clear. In fpgs1, there were 19 glycan epitopes of higher levels and four of lower levels, compared with the double mutant. By contrast, there were 15 glycan epitopes with lower levels and only three with higher levels in ccoamt1, compared with the double mutant (Additional file 4: Fig S2). Very few selected epitopes showed similar trends between fpgs1 and ccoaomt1 when each was compared against the double mutant. These changes indicated subtle structure changes in the non-cellulosic components of cell wall among WT plants and the single and double fpgs1 ccoamt1 mutants.
Metabolic profiling displayed shifts in phenylpropanoid pathway in fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and fpgs1ccoaomt1 mutants
Metabolite analysis of 6-week-old Arabidopsis stems was performed by gas chromatography mass spectrometry (GC–MS) to determine the impact on metabolism after the disruption of FPGS1, CCOAOMT1, or FPGS1/CCOAOMT1 combined expression relative to non-disrupted expression in WT stems. More than 100 peaks were detected in the stem tissues of all four genotypes. The top 100 peaks were chosen for analysis, and 77 of them were of known chemical structures (Additional file 5: Fig. S3). Based on P < 0.05, levels for 25, 31, and 30 metabolites were significantly different from WT for fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and the double-mutant, fpgs1ccoaomt1, respectively. Comparing the levels of detected compounds among all genotypes revealed that the metabolite profile for the fpgs1ccoaomt1 double mutant was more similar to ccoaomt1 than to fpgs1 (Fig. 5a; Additional file 5: Fig S3).
Levels of nine compounds were uniquely changed in the fpgs1 mutant versus WT stem tissue. Among them, four sugars were decreased: glucose, fructose, 3,6-anhydrogalactose, and galactose (Fig. 5a, Additional file 6: Table S3). Levels of three compounds—maleic acid, glutamic acid, and sucrose—were uniquely increased in ccoaomt1 (Fig. 5a, Additional file 6: Table S3). Levels for 13 compounds exhibited similar alterations in all three mutants compared with WT, with 11 increased and two decreases (Fig. 5a). Phenylalanine and shikimic acid were among the compounds with significant decreases (Fig. 5b). Among the compounds that were increased in levels in all three mutants, guaiacyl lignan and sinapoyl-malic acid are directly related to the phenylpropanoid pathway (Fig. 5c and d, Additional file 6: Table S3).
For another 13 compounds, levels for 12 were increased and one (threonic acid) decreased similarly in ccoaomt1 and double mutants compared with values from WT tissue. Levels of these compounds were unchanged in fpgs1 mutant tissue compared with WT tissue. A significant number of metabolites related to the phenylpropanoid/flavonoid pathways are among this group of metabolites which increased in the ccoaomt1 and double-mutant tissue: ferulic acid, 2-O-feruloyl-malic acid, and 16.25 398 383 glucoside, increased fivefold or more; two flavonoid compounds, syringic acid-4-O-glucoside and vanillic acid-4-O-glucoside, increased approximately twofold; sinapic acid, a precursor of syringyl lignin and bioactive compound within the cell walls, increased one-third and an increase in compound 2-O-feruloyl-malic acid was only detectable in ccoaomt1 and the double mutant among four genotypes (Fig. 5b, c; Additional file 6: Table S3). There were only two metabolites of levels that increased in the double-mutant tissue compared with each single-mutant tissue, and they were guaiacyl lignan and kaempferol (Fig. 5d; Additional file 6: Table S3), which are direct products of the phenylpropanoid pathway.
Transcript profiling of fpgs1ccoaomt1 mutant tissue reveals molecular impacts of lignin biosynthesis pathway by FPGS1 and CCoAOMT1
Transcriptomes of single and double mutants of fpgs1 and ccoaomt1 were investigated in 6-week-old Arabidopsis stems. A total of 392 differentially expressed genes were identified among fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and the double mutant compared with WT. There were 161, 250, and 234 upregulated and 13, 22, and 25 downregulated genes in fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and the double-mutant stem tissue, respectively, when compared with WT stem tissue. The quality of the microarray data was supported by examining expression levels of the two target genes, FPGS1 and CCoAOMT1. Both showed less than 10% of wild-type levels in the corresponding single or double mutants (Table 2). Visualization of differentially expressed genes showed that 97 genes had the same expression patterns among mutant lines. Fifty-eight genes had changed expression only in the double mutant, 86 genes only in ccoaomt1 and 15 genes only in fpgs1. The differentially expressed gene list in the double mutant substantially overlapped with that of ccoaomt1 (Additional file 7: Fig. S4).
Genes encoding proteins in the phenylpropanoid/lignin biosynthesis pathway were among the group of genes with significant expression alterations in single or double mutants. For instance, a significant number of genes encoding Kelch domain-containing F-Box (KFB) proteins, which are negative regulators mediating phenylalanine ammonia lyase (PAL) proteolytic turnover through ubiquitination-26S proteasome pathway [55, 56], changed expression in single and double mutants (Table 2). Consistent with the decreased expression of KFB genes, PAL2 transcripts increased in all three mutants, although at less than the twofold ratio cutoff. In the middle and later part of the lignin biosynthesis pathway, At1g80820 (AtCCR2) and At1g20510 (4CL-like1/OPC-8:0 CoA ligase1, OPCL1) were upregulated in both single and double mutants. A number of PEROXIDASE (Prx) and LACCASE (LAC) genes also exhibited altered expression levels in the mutant backgrounds. For example, At2g29130 (AtLAC2) was significantly downregulated in fpgs1 and slightly upregulated in ccoaomt1 and the double mutant. Furthermore, At2g37130 (AtPrx21) was significantly downregulated in ccoaomt1 and the double mutant while slightly upregulated in fpgs1 (Table 2). Among the transcription factors that have been shown to be involved in the regulation of phenylpropanoid/lignin biosynthesis, expression of AtMYB4 (At4g38620), a key negative regulator of the phenylpropanoid acids and esters pathway, was significantly downregulated in all three mutants. Expression levels of genes involved in other aspects of wall synthesis were also altered in the mutants. These genes included CELLULOSE-SYNTHASE LIKE C4 (AtCSLC4), XYLOGLUCAN ENDOTRANSGLUCOSYLASE/HYDROLASE22 (AtXTH22), TOXICOS EN LEVADURA2 and three genes that encode expansin-like (EXPL) proteins (Table 2).
The number of genes differentially expressed between each single and the double mutant was very small, 10 for fpgs1 and 21 for ccoaomt1 (Additional file 8: Table S4). Noticeably, there was significant representation of genes involved in the downstream portions of the C1 and lignin pathways. For example, four genes that were downregulated in all three mutants were from the pathway involved in tryptophan-derived indole glucosinolate metabolism (Table 2), which is tightly linked to methionine metabolism . Increase of transcripts of the glucosinolate biosynthesis genes was also seen in earlier work in Arabidopsis mutants with reduced lignin . These genes included 2-oxoglutarate-dependent dioxygenase (AOP3) and indole glucosinolate methyltransferase 2, 3, and 4 (IGMT2, IGMT3, and IGMT4). Expression of homocysteine S-methyltransferase3 (HMT3), which is involved in the S-methylmethionine (SMM) cycle responsible for the cycling of methionine and controlling the level of AdoMet in plants , also was reduced significantly in the double mutant compared with each of the single mutants. Other differentially expressed genes involved in phenylpropanoid/lignin biosynthesis that changed expression between the single and the double mutant included AtCCR2, KFB39, and AtPrx21 (Table 2).
Previous studies have shown that single ccoaomt1 [22, 35] and fpgs1  mutants have reduced lignin levels. Here we expanded work on analysis of these single mutants and determined whether lignin levels could be further reduced in fpgs1ccoaomt1 double mutants without compromising plant growth. The fpgs1ccoaomt1 double mutants had the lowest total AcBr-based lignin content and the highest sugar release when compared to WT and single-mutant plants fpgs1 and ccoaomt1 (Fig. 3, Table 1). The additional reduction in lignin observed in fpgs1ccoaomt1 tissue with minimal or no impact on plant growth suggests that FPGS1 and CCOAOMT1 are suitable gene targets for simultaneous downregulation to further improve plants for biofuel production beyond single-gene downregulation.
To better understand how disruption of both FPGS1 and CCoAOMT1 led to plants with further decreased lignin content and additional sugar release, we conducted glycomics, metabolomics, and transcriptomics studies on WT, fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and fpgs1ccoaomt1 stem tissue. Although data analyses revealed global differences among the various genotypes (i.e., between WT, single, and double mutants), such differences were minor. Overall, the double mutant mainly resembled the ccoaomt1 single mutant, with minor additional changes contributed by the effects of the FPGS1 mutation, leading to a further-improved saccharification efficiency. To allow comparison of wall analysis traits with transcriptome data using developmentally matched tissues, we completed lignin content, saccharification efficiency, and various -omic studies using green mature stem tissue. Future studies will be important to ascertain whether the double mutant maintains its improved sugar accessibility in senesced stem tissue which is most often used for biofuel production. Baxter et al.  noted the importance of analyzing both live green and senesced tissues for industry purposes. They found lower lignin content and greater enzymatic sugar release were consistent for both green and senesced aerial tissue of switchgrass downregulated for COMT activity.
In plants, shikimic acid from the shikimate pathway provides the backbone for synthesis of the aromatic amino acids (phenylalanine, tyrosine, and tryptophan), which serve as intermediates for a wide range of important metabolites, including lignin and folates [60, 61] (Additional file 9: Fig. S5). Phenylalanine (Phe) is the starting material for the phenylpropanoid pathway, which leads to lignin production. Significant reductions in shikimic acid and phenylalanine in all three mutants indicate that disruption of FPGS1 and CCoAOMT1 alone or together led to feedback adjustment at the entry point of the pathway, which could be a very efficient regulation mechanism of the phenylpropanoid pathway and its downstream branches (Additional file 9: Fig. S5). Feedback regulations of the phenylpropanoid pathway also has been observed after mutating different genes in this pathway, such as UGT78D1/D2 or C4H [62,63,64]. Even though levels of intermediate products as well as the downstream lignin content and compositions are different between tissues from fpgs1 and ccoaomt1 mutant lines, the double-mutant tissue does not have additive downregulation of Phe level, indicating the feedback changes are very sensitive but with limited capacity in response to downstream changes. Although expression of most genes in the early portion of the phenylpropanoid pathway are slightly higher in the mutants, it is worth pointing out that PAL2, the major gene that controls the entry point to this pathway and whose expression is negatively regulated by the downstream products , was significantly upregulated in all three mutants. Expression of PAL2 increased by 26%, 83%, and 73% in fpgs1, ccoaomat1, and the double mutant, respectively, compared to WT. Our results are consistent with previous observations that feedback regulation at the entry point of the phenylpropanoid pathway can occur at both transcriptional and enzyme activity levels in different plant species [62,63,64,65]. Changes in the expression of genes within the lignin biosynthetic pathway suggest a pathway-wide retuning when one or more steps of the pathway are disturbed. Often these changes were carried through a particular member of the gene family as observed by Vanholme et al. . In plants, AtCCR2 and its orthologs are considered to be involved in the biosynthesis of phenolics whose accumulation may respond readily to different conditions [66,67,68]. On the other hand, the main family member involved in lignin biosynthesis, AtCCR1, does not change expression levels even when there are changes in lignin content .
Differences of lignin monomer profiles in single and double mutants in comparison to WT plants indicate that regulation of different types of lignin monomer production is dynamic, as observed by studies of lignin mutants in various species [23, 69]. Modification of one step or branch of the lignin pathway will result in changes in other steps or branches of the pathway. While changes of metabolites in fpgs1 are mostly limited to sugars, sugar alcohols, and amino acids (Additional file 5: Fig. S3), there are significant shifts in the metabolites associated with phenylpropanoid pathway in the stem from ccoaomt1 mutant. Despite the fact that both G- and S- lignins are reduced in the ccoaomt1 mutant stem tissue, its increased S/G ratio suggests that some S-monomer units may come from another metabolic pathway in the ccoaomt1 plant, bypassing the CCoAOMT step. Using stable isotope labeling, sinapic acid (SA) was shown to be converted to S-lignin through sinapoyl-CoA and sinapaldehyde in Robinia pseudoacacia and Nerium indicum . Although only a side pathway in the poplar and Arabidopsis , the path from SA to S-lignin might become more active when the main pathway to s-monomer production is impaired, as in the case of a mutation in CCoAOMT1 gene. The increased ferulic acid (FA), SA, and sinapoyl malate levels in the ccoaomt1 mutant provided evidence that the phenylpropanoid pathway redirects the flow of metabolites preferentially toward two downstream branches. Preferential flow toward one branch leads to the increased production of sinapoyl malate while the other branches toward S-monomer production through sinapoyl-CoA and sinapaldehyde. Similar to findings with ccoaomt1 tissue, levels of FA, SA, and sinapoyl malate were also significantly increased in fpgs1ccoaomt1 tissue. The lignin composition in the fpgs1ccoaomt1 double-mutant tissue likely reflects the combined effects of each single mutant. For example, G- and S- lignin levels of fpgs1ccoaomt1 were similar to ccoaomt1, while H-levels were the combined effect of each single mutant.
In addition to lignin, levels of several secondary metabolites also were altered in the single and double mutants when compared to WT. Most notable were those in the phenylpropanoic acid and ester metabolism pathways. The significant increases in ferulic acid, sinapic acid, feruloyl malate, and sinapoyl malate in both ccoaomt1 and the double mutant are likely redirected metabolites caused by excess caffeoyl-coA that accumulated due to mutation of the CCoAOMT1 gene. Similar increases in feruloyl malate and sinapoyl malate were observed in mutants/RNAi lines for the gene next downstream in the pathway, namely, ccr1 mutant in Arabidopsis and PtCCR downregulated lines in poplar [67, 68]. Similar to poplar tissue downregulated CCR- and CCoAOMT expression [21, 68], ccoaomt1 single and fpgs1ccoaomt1 double mutants accumulated syringic acid-4-O-glucoside and vanillic acid-4-O-glucoside, both readily produced from the accumulated ferulic acid . In these mutants, G- and S-lignin production would be interrupted and the influx of p-coumaroyl CoA presumably would be diverted to the biosynthesis of flavonoids such as kaempferol and quercetin as seen in the mutants in this study and early reports [23, 35] (Fig. 5). Additional modifications of metabolite content in the double mutant contributed by the FPGS1 mutation were very few, with only two metabolites (kaempferol and guaiacyl lignan) exhibiting obvious additional increases.
The observed increase of lignan in the double mutant seemed unusual considering contradictory with the reduced lignin in all mutants. One might expect that a reduction of G-lignin would also result in a reduction in guaiacyl lignans, given that they both are derived from the same precursor . However, it cannot be assumed that a reduction in G-lignin dictates or necessitates a decline in all guaiacyl lignans, because they are synthesized and are located in different tissues/organs and are likely sourced from different compartmentalized substrate pools. The G-lignin measured by thioacidolysis and NMR reported in this study is from wall-bound polymeric lignin. Guaiacyl lignan measured by GC–MS was from the ethanol-soluble metabolites pool. The overall wall-bound lignins, especially G-lignin, are one of the most abundant substrates of plant secondary cell wall. Compared to other metabolites in the GC–MS analysis, the lignan level is relatively low, ranging from 0.8 to 2 ug/g fresh weight (sorbitol equivalents), which accounts for a very small portion of coniferyl alcohol derivatives and will not likely change the overall picture of lowered G-lignin content in the mutants compared with WT nor the fact that the double mutant has less lignin than each single mutant. The reason why the guaiacyl lignan has a small but accumulated increase in the double mutants is not obviously based on the current work. We speculate that this could be attributed to the changed phenylpropanoid pathway feedback rechanneling of metabolites to other side branches. Future work focusing more deeply on ethanol-soluble lignin precursors in these mutants will be needed in order to understand the lignan regulation in relation to the wall-bound lignin modifications.
Our work provided additional insights into interactions among genes involved in lignin biosynthesis. For example, the role of the AtMYB4 transcription factor in regulating downstream lignin pathway genes is not fully understood. Although the expression of CCoAOMT was reduced in the atmyb4 mutant and increased in AtMYB4 overexpression lines , a direct interaction between AtMYB4 and the CCoAOMT promoter was not shown. It was not clear if AtMYB4 decreased the expression of a repressor of CCoAOMT to regulate its level or the expression of CCoAOMT simply responded to metabolic feedback regulation . In this study, although AtMYB4 transcript levels were reduced in all three mutants, the expression level of CCoAOMT was not affected in the fpgs1 mutant tissue (Table 2). This result indicates that correlation of the expression level of CCoAOMT to that of MYB4 reported earlier  is most likely due to metabolic feedback regulation.
The similarity in the glycome profiles among WT, fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and fpgs1ccoaomt1 plants indicated that no major non-cellulosic glycans are modified among the single and double mutants due to FPGS1 and CCOAOMT1 mutations. The increased extractabilities for non-cellulosic carbohydrates from cell wall of the mutants, in particular of the double mutant, are likely attributed to lignin structure and composition changes. These changes could lead to the loosening of the cell-wall secondary structures, which enables better access to cellulose components for increased sugar release in the double mutants, especially when no pretreatment was applied. In this study, reduced lignin content among all three mutants and changed S/G ratios in both ccoaomt1 and the double mutant indicated lignin modification is likely the main cause of reduced recalcitrance in the mutants. Changes of transcripts levels for genes encoding enzymes involved in lignin polymerization such as laccases and type III peroxidases [74,75,76,77,78] provide molecular evidence for lignin structure modifications. In addition, 2D HSQC-NMR analysis revealed changes in interunit linkages of the lignin in the mutants that provide direct evidence of structural alterations, derived mainly from CCoAOMT1 mutation. Together these data provide comprehensive insights into the reduced recalcitrance and other likely changes in the mutants unrelated to lignin. With regard to the latter, global changes in the mutant uncovered by transcriptomics and glycomics reported here could guide future studies on previously undescribed physiological processes impacted by CCoAOMT1 and FPGS1.
In this work, we show that additional reductions in lignin content and improved sugar release can be achieved by simultaneous downregulation of genes in the C1 (FPGS1) and lignin biosynthetic (CCoAOMT1) pathway. The double mutant exhibited a combined profile of lignin content and composition derived from each single mutant and improved sugar release. Omics data show that the double mutant resembled mostly the ccoaomt1 mutant. Changes introduced by FPGS1 mutation in the double mutant indicate that the lignin pathway can be further modified to achieve improved saccharification efficiency with minimal or no impact to growth in Arabidopsis. These findings can now be applied to studies with poplar, switchgrass, or other biofuel crops to determine the generality of these results across species and its applicability for the biofuel industry.
Plant materials and growth conditions
The ccoaomt1 (SALK_151507) T-DNA line was obtained from the Arabidopsis Biological Resource Center (ABRC) at The Ohio State University. The fpgs1 was the T-DNA line originally designated as atdfb-1 or fpgs1-1 and identified through a forward genetic screen [43, 51]. Both ccoaomt1 and fpgs1 lines reside in the Columbia (Col-0) genetic background. Double fpgs1ccoaomt1 mutants were generated by first crossing the two single homozygous mutants. The F1 was then self-fertilized, and the resulting F2 generation genotyped at the DNA level to find the homozygous double mutants. Confirmed double homozygous plants were self-fertilized to obtain seed used for the experiments. Wild-type and homozygous fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and fpgs1ccoaomt1 plants were confirmed by RT-PCR where the mutant lacks amplifications for its relevant target transcripts. The primers used for genotyping and RT-PCR are listed in Additional file 1: Table S1. All plants analyzed were grown in the same growth chamber to ensure uniform environmental conditions (16/8 h light/dark, 100 µmol photons m−2 s−1 light, 60% relative humidity, and temperature of 23 °C in the day, 21 °C at night) [43, 75].
Phenotypic characterization of fpgs1ccoaomt1 double mutant and preparation of plant material for analysis
Seeds of all genotypes were vertically grown on 0.7% agar plates supplemented with half strength Murashige and Skoog medium (pH 5.7) containing 1% (w/v) sucrose for roots phenotyping . Another set of seeds was directly sown into soil and grown in the growth chamber for plant tissue collections . Arabidopsis plants were grown in a mixture of Metro-Mix 350 (Sun Gro Horticulture, Agawam, Massachusetts) and Metro-Mix 830 (Sun Gro Horticulture, Agawam, Massachusetts) at a 1-to-1 ratio. The pH of the mixture was in the 5.4–7.5 range. Fertilizer was not added at the early stage because all Metro-Mix formulas contain a starter nutrient level sufficient for Arabidopsis seedling development. When the plants started to bolt, they were watered with solution supplemented with fertilizer (Peters 20–10–20 = N–P–K) as needed . When the plants were 6 weeks old and the first silique started to turn yellow, the aboveground part of the plants was collected to quantify whole plant and stem fresh weight. The stems, which were devoid of leaves, siliques, and flowers, were dried for lignin, sugar release, and glycome-profiling analyses. The stem materials for microarray and metabolite analysis were collected directly from the plants in the growth chamber by removing the leaves, siliques, and flowers, and then immediately frozen in liquid nitrogen. The plant material used for each analysis had at least three biological replicates with each replicate pooled from at least 20 plants.
RT-PCR, qRT-PCR, and microarray analysis
Nine-day-old plate-grown wild-type, fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and fpgs1ccoaomt1 whole seedlings were collected for RT-PCR analysis to analyze target genes FPGS1 and CCoAOMT1 expression. Wild-type Arabidopsis plants at two stages of development were used for gene expression analysis by real-time qRT-PCR. Whole seedlings of 2-week-old plate-grown Arabidopsis plants and 6-week-old mature Arabidopsis plant tissue were used for RNA isolation. For the latter, stem tissue from various portions of the plant were sampled as shown in Fig. 1. For microarray analysis, whole stem tissue without leaves and flower parts were harvested from 6-week-old wild-type, fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and fpgs1ccoaomt1 plants.
Total RNA was isolated by Spectrum Plant Total RNA Kit (Sigma-Aldrich) and Turbo DNase treatment was applied to remove DNA contamination. The cDNA was synthesized by Superscript III Reverse Transcriptase (Invitrogen). qRT-PCR was run on a 7900HT, and the data were analyzed by SDS 2.4.1 software (machine and software, Applied Biosystems, Foster City, California).
Total RNA from 6-week-old mature stems of WT, single, and double mutants was used for microarray analysis. RNA quantification and quality control were conducted by Bioanalyzer, NanoDrop, and Qubit. Affymetrix Arabidopsis ATH1 Genome Array was used for labeling. The experiment was performed according to manufacturer’s instructions. Microarray data were submitted to ArrayExpress with accession number of E-MTAB-7536. Data were normalized using Robust Multichip Average algorithms. Differentially expressed (DE) genes were selected using associative analysis  from fpgs1, ccoaomt1, and fpgs1ccoaomt1 using a ratio cutoff of two and P-value cutoff of 2.19 × 10−6 (derived from Bonferroni-corrected P value (0.05/22,810) of the ATH1 chip). The selected genes were first preprocessed to one of the Cytoscape-supported XML-based exchange formats by using a custom PYTHON script. This XML file was imported to Cytoscape  and visualized by using yFiles Layouts. All up- and downregulated genes were highlighted in red and blue, respectively.
Determination of lignin composition and acetyl bromide (AcBr) lignin content
Stems harvested from 6-week-old mature plants were dried in a 37 °C oven for 7 days and then ground by 20 Mesh Wiley mill. The ground materials were extracted through successive steps by methanol, chloroform: methanol (2:1 v/v), methanol, and water to acquire alcohol-insoluble residue (AIR) . Around 20 mg AIR was used to determine lignin content by the acetyl bromide (AcBr) method [52, 83]. The thioacidolysis method was used to determine lignin composition. Approximately 15 mg AIR was used to produce lignin monomers by thioacidolysis. The lignin-derived monomers (S, G, H) were identified and quantified by gas chromatography mass spectrometry (GC/MS) as described previously [84, 85]. The relative content for each lignin monomer obtained by thioacidolysis analysis was calculated for every 100 mg of AIR.
Analysis of total sugar and enzymatic sugar
The AIR material for lignin analysis was also used for total sugar and enzymatic sugar determination according to previously described procedures [30, 43]. To focus on total hydrates from lignocellulose and not total cell polysaccharides, the AIR material was destarched using amylase assay solution (α-amylase [Sigma): amyloglucosidase [Sigma] = 1:1 in citrate buffer [0.1 M, pH 5.0]). To release total sugar from all wall carbohydrates, about 7.5 mg destarched AIR material was treated with 72% H2SO4 at 30 °C for 1 h, then diluted by water, prior being autoclaved at 121 °C for 1 h to obtain simple sugars. Sugar content was analyzed using the phenol–sulfuric acid sugar assay [30, 86].
For enzymatic hydrolysis sugar release analysis, material was digested with a cellulase enzyme mix to ensure sugars from cellulose were released, as described previously : to summarize, approximately 10 mg destarched AIR material was digested in 20 ul of a cellulase stock from Trichoderma reesei (Sigma-Aldrich) and Novozyme 188 stock from Aspergillus niger (Sigma-Aldrich) mixture in a 1:1 ratio in 2.5 ml citrate buffer (0.1 M, pH 5.0) at 50 °C for 72 h. Enzymatic hydrolyzed sugar content was measured by the phenol–sulfuric acid sugar assay [30, 86]. This analysis method was described in detail in our previous publication .
Whole cell-wall NMR analysis and glycome profiling
Using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) technology [87, 88], the degree of the complex structures of lignin polymers was examined for the mutants and wild-type plants. The AIR material for lignin analysis was also used for whole cell-wall NMR analysis and glycome profiling.
For whole cell-wall NMR analysis, the AIR material was extracted by ethanol/toluene solvent (1:2 v/v) for 12 h and vacuum-dried for 48 h. The extract-free samples were ball-milled at 580 rpm for 4 h. About 80 mg of ball-milled biomass was dissolved/soaked in 0.5 mL of DMSO-d6/HMPA-d18 for NMR analysis. NMR spectra were acquired at 298 K using a Bruker Avance III 400 MHz console equipped with a 5-mm BBO probe. The central DMSO solvent peaks (δH/δC = 2.49/39.5 ppm) were used for chemical shift calibration. Two-dimensional 1H-13C heteronuclear single-quantum coherence (HSQC) spectra were collected using a Bruker standard pulse sequence (‘hequetgpsi2’). Volume integration of cross peaks in HSQC spectra was carried out using Bruker’s TopSpin 3.5 software.
For glycome profiling, the AIR material was extracted sequentially with increasingly harsh reagents . The sequential resultant extracts were analyzed for carbohydrates by phenol–sulphuric acid assays and were also screened with a large collection of plant glycan-directed monoclonal antibodies by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays, as described previously . Briefly, each extraction step consists of increasingly harsh reagents in the following order: ammonium oxalate (AO, 1st), sodium carbonate (2nd), 1 M KOH (3rd), 4 M KOH (4th), acidic sodium chlorite (5th), and 4 M KOH PC (postchlorite treatment, 6th) [89,90,91]. Presence of each carbohydrate epitope was detected by the enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) using glycan-directed monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) against respective cell-wall extracts.
Approximately 90 mg of ground 6-week-old fresh stem material was weighed into a 15-ml centrifuge tube containing 2 ml of 80% ethanol and 15 ul of sorbitol (1 mg/ml) added as an internal standard. Samples were extracted at RT overnight with end-over-end rotation, centrifuged at 4500 rpm for 20 min, and then decanted into scintillation vials that were stored at − 20 °C. An additional 1 ml of 80% ethanol was added to the plant residue and a second extraction was performed at RT overnight. After centrifugation, the second extract was combined with the first extract and mixed well, and 2 ml of the combined extract was dried under nitrogen. The dried extract was dissolved in 0.5 ml acetonitrile and silylated to generate trimethylsilyl derivatives, as described previously . After 2 days, 1ul aliquots were injected into an Agilent 5975C inert XL gas chromatograph-mass spectrometer (GC–MS). The single quadrupole GC–MS was operated in the electron impact (70 eV) mode, targeting 2.5 full-spectrum (50–650 Da) scans per second, as described previously . Metabolomic measurements were made, as described previously .
Thompson PB. The agricultural ethics of biofuels: the food vs. fuel debate. Agriculture. 2012;2(4):339–58.
Converse AO. Renewable energy in the United States. Appl Biochem Biotechnol. 2007;137(1–12):611–24.
Larkum AW, Ross IL, Kruse O, Hankamer B. Selection, breeding and engineering of microalgae for bioenergy and biofuel production. Trends Biotechnol. 2012;30(4):198–205.
Moon HS, Abercrombie JM, Kausch AP, Stewart CN. Sustainable use of biotechnology for bioenergy feedstocks. Environ Manage. 2010;46(4):531–8.
Iiyama K, Lam TB-T, Stone BA. Covalent cross-links in the cell wall. Plant Physiol. 1994;104(2):315–20.
Hatfield R, Ralph J, Grabber J. Cell wall structural foundations: molecular basis for improving forage digestibilities. Crop Sci. 1999;39(1):27–37.
Hatfield RD, Rancour DM, Marita JM. Grass cell walls: a story of cross-linking. Front Plant Sci. 2017;7:2056.
Nishimura H, Kamiya A, Nagata T, Katahira M, Watanabe T. Direct evidence for α ether linkage between lignin and carbohydrates in wood cell walls. Sci Rep. 2018;8:6538.
Boerjan W, Ralph J, Baucher M. Lignin biosynthesis. Annu Rev Plant Biol. 2003;54(1):519–46.
Xie M, Zhang J, Tschaplinski TJ, Tuskan GA, Chen J-G, Muchero W. Regulation of lignin biosynthesis and its role in growth-defense tradeoffs. Front Plant Sci. 2018;9:1427.
Jung H, Allen M. Characteristics of plant cell walls affecting intake and digestibility of forages by ruminants. J Anim Sci. 1995;73(9):2774–90.
Abdeshahian P, Dashti M, Kalil MS, Yusoff WMW. Production of biofuel using biomass as a sustainable biological resource. Biotechnology. 2010;9(3):274–82.
Bonawitz ND, Chapple C. The genetics of lignin biosynthesis: connecting genotype to phenotype. Annu Rev Genet. 2010;44:337–63.
Isikgor FH, Becer CR. Lignocellulosic biomass: a sustainable platform for the production of bio-based chemicals and polymers. Polym Chem. 2015;6(25):4497–559.
Saini JK, Saini R, Tewari L. Lignocellulosic agriculture wastes as biomass feedstocks for second-generation bioethanol production: concepts and recent developments. 3 Biotech. 2015;5(4):337–53.
Jung JG, Samac DA, Sarath G. Modifying crops to increase cell wall digestibility. Plant Sci. 2012;185:65–77.
Barros J, Serk H, Granlund I, Pesquet E. The cell biology of lignification in higher plants. Ann Bot. 2015;115(7):1053–74.
Schuetz M, Smith R, Ellis B. Xylem tissue specification, patterning, and differentiation mechanisms. J Exp Bot. 2012;64(1):11–31.
Smith A, Giordano A, Mouradov A. Metabolic reprogramming of lignin biosynthesis in crops. Signpost Open Access J NanoPhotoBioSciences. 2013;1:93–117.
Fraser CM, Chapple C. The phenylpropanoid pathway in Arabidopsis. Arabidopsis Book. 2011;8:e0152.
Zhong R, Morrison WH, Himmelsbach DS, Poole FL, Ye Z-H. Essential role of caffeoyl coenzyme A O-methyltransferase in lignin biosynthesis in woody poplar plants. Plant Physiol. 2000;124(2):563–78.
Do C-T, Pollet B, Thévenin J, Sibout R, Denoue D, Barrière Y, Lapierre C, Jouanin L. Both caffeoyl Coenzyme A 3-O-methyltransferase 1 and caffeic acid O-methyltransferase 1 are involved in redundant functions for lignin, flavonoids and sinapoyl malate biosynthesis in Arabidopsis. Planta. 2007;226(5):1117–29.
Vanholme R, Storme V, Vanholme B, Sundin L, Christensen JH, Goeminne G, Halpin C, Rohde A, Morreel K, Boerjan W. A systems biology view of responses to lignin biosynthesis perturbations in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell. 2012;24(9):3506–29.
Ye Z-H, Kneusel RE, Matern U, Varner JE. An alternative methylation pathway in lignin biosynthesis in Zinnia. Plant Cell. 1994;6(10):1427–39.
Zhong R, Morrison WH, Negrel J, Ye Z-H. Dual methylation pathways in lignin biosynthesis. Plant Cell. 1998;10(12):2033–45.
Eckardt NA. Probing the mysteries of lignin biosynthesis: the crystal structure of caffeic acid/5-hydroxyferulic acid 3/5-O-methyltransferase provides new insights. Plant Cell. 2002;14(6):1185–9.
Pinçon G, Maury S, Hoffmann L, Geoffroy P, Lapierre C, Pollet B, Legrand M. Repression of O-methyltransferase genes in transgenic tobacco affects lignin synthesis and plant growth. Phytochemistry. 2001;57(7):1167–76.
Meyermans H, Morreel K, Lapierre C, Pollet B, De Bruyn A, Busson R, Herdewijn P, Devreese B, Van Beeumen J, Marita JM. Modifications in lignin and accumulation of phenolic glucosides in poplar xylem upon down-regulation of caffeoyl-coenzyme A O-methyltransferase, an enzyme involved in lignin biosynthesis. J Biol Chem. 2000;275(47):36899–909.
Marita JM, Ralph J, Hatfield RD, Guo D, Chen F, Dixon RA. Structural and compositional modifications in lignin of transgenic alfalfa down-regulated in caffeic acid 3-O-methyltransferase and caffeoyl coenzyme A 3-O-methyltransferase. Phytochemistry. 2003;62(1):53–65.
Chen F, Dixon RA. Lignin modification improves fermentable sugar yields for biofuel production. Nat Biotechnol. 2007;25(7):759.
Guo D, Chen F, Inoue K, Blount JW, Dixon RA. Downregulation of caffeic acid 3-O-methyltransferase and caffeoyl CoA 3-O-methyltransferase in transgenic alfalfa: impacts on lignin structure and implications for the biosynthesis of G and S lignin. Plant Cell. 2001;13(1):73–88.
Day A, Neutelings G, Nolin F, Grec S, Habrant A, Crônier D, Maher B, Rolando C, David H, Chabbert B. Caffeoyl coenzyme A O-methyltransferase down-regulation is associated with modifications in lignin and cell-wall architecture in flax secondary xylem. Plant Physiol Biochem. 2009;47(1):9–19.
Wagner A, Tobimatsu Y, Phillips L, Flint H, Torr K, Donaldson L, Pears L, Ralph J. CCoAOMT suppression modifies lignin composition in Pinus radiata. Plant J. 2011;67(1):119–29.
Li X, Chen W, Zhao Y, Xiang Y, Jiang H, Zhu S, Cheng B. Downregulation of caffeoyl-CoA O-methyltransferase (CCoAOMT) by RNA interference leads to reduced lignin production in maize straw. Genetics Mol Biol. 2013;36(4):540–6.
Van Acker R, Vanholme R, Storme V, Mortimer JC, Dupree P, Boerjan W. Lignin biosynthesis perturbations affect secondary cell wall composition and saccharification yield in Arabidopsis thaliana. Biotechnol Biofuels. 2013;6(1):46.
Raes J, Rohde A, Christensen JH, Van de Peer Y, Boerjan W. Genome-wide characterization of the lignification toolbox in Arabidopsis. Plant Physiol. 2003;133(3):1051–71.
Zhang Y, Sun K, Sandoval FJ, Santiago K, Roje S. One-carbon metabolism in plants: characterization of a plastid serine hydroxymethyltransferase. Biochem J. 2010;430(1):97–105.
Hanson AD, Gage DA, Shachar-Hill Y. Plant one-carbon metabolism and its engineering. Trends Plant Sci. 2000;5(5):206–13.
Hanson AD, Roje S. One-carbon metabolism in higher plants. Annu Rev Plant Biol. 2001;52(1):119–37.
Shen B, Li C, Tarczynski MC. High free-methionine and decreased lignin content result from a mutation in the Arabidopsis S-adenosyl-l-methionine synthetase 3 gene. Plant J. 2002;29(3):371–80.
Tang HM, Liu S, Hill-Skinner S, Wu W, Reed D, Yeh CT, Nettleton D, Schnable PS. The maize brown midrib2 (bm2) gene encodes a methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase that contributes to lignin accumulation. Plant J. 2014;77(3):380–92.
Li L, Hill-Skinner S, Liu S, Beuchle D, Tang HM, Yeh CT, Nettleton D, Schnable PS. The maize brown midrib4 (bm4) gene encodes a functional folylpolyglutamate synthase. Plant J. 2015;81(3):493–504.
Srivastava AC, Chen F, Ray T, Pattathil S, Peña MJ, Avci U, Li H, Huhman DV, Backe J, Urbanowicz B. Loss of function of folylpolyglutamate synthetase 1 reduces lignin content and improves cell wall digestibility in Arabidopsis. Biotechnol Biofuels. 2015;8(1):224.
Shigeto J, Itoh Y, Hirao S, Ohira K, Fujita K, Tsutsumi Y. Simultaneously disrupting AtPrx2, AtPrx25 and AtPrx71 alters lignin content and structure in Arabidopsis stem. J Integr Plant Biol. 2015;57(4):349–56.
de Vries L, Vanholme R, Van Acker R, De Meester B, Sundin L, Boerjan W. Stacking of a low-lignin trait with an increased guaiacyl and 5-hydroxyguaiacyl unit trait leads to additive and synergistic effects on saccharification efficiency in Arabidopsis thaliana. Biotechnol Biofuels. 2018;11(1):257.
Chabannes M, Barakate A, Lapierre C, Marita JM, Ralph J, Pean M, Danoun S, Halpin C, Grima-Pettenati J, Boudet AM. Strong decrease in lignin content without significant alteration of plant development is induced by simultaneous down-regulation of cinnamoyl CoA reductase (CCR) and cinnamyl alcohol dehydrogenase (CAD) in tobacco plants. Plant J. 2001;28(3):257–70.
Nelson RS, Stewart CN, Gou J, Holladay S, Gallego-Giraldo L, Flanagan A, Mann DG, Hisano H, Wuddineh WA, Poovaiah CR. Development and use of a switchgrass (Panicum virgatum L.) transformation pipeline by the BioEnergy Science Center to evaluate plants for reduced cell wall recalcitrance. Biotechnol Biofuels. 2017;10(1):309.
Bonawitz ND, Im Kim J, Tobimatsu Y, Ciesielski PN, Anderson NA, Ximenes E, Maeda J, Ralph J, Donohoe BS, Ladisch M. Disruption of mediator rescues the stunted growth of a lignin-deficient Arabidopsis mutant. Nature. 2014;509(7500):376.
Anderson NA, Tobimatsu Y, Ciesielski PN, Ximenes E, Ralph J, Donohoe BS, Ladisch M, Chapple C. Manipulation of guaiacyl and syringyl monomer biosynthesis in an Arabidopsis cinnamyl alcohol dehydrogenase mutant results in atypical lignin biosynthesis and modified cell wall structure. Plant Cell. 2015;27:2195–209.
Wu Z, Wang N, Hisano H, Cao Y, Wu F, Liu W, Bao Y, Wang ZY, Fu C. Simultaneous regulation of F5H in COMT-RNA i transgenic switchgrass alters effects of COMT suppression on syringyl lignin biosynthesis. Plant Biotechnol J. 2018;17:836–45.
Srivastava AC, Ramos-Parra PA, Bedair M, Robledo-Hernández AL, Tang Y, Sumner LW, de la Garza RID, Blancaflor EB. The folylpolyglutamate synthetase plastidial isoform is required for postembryonic root development in Arabidopsis. Plant Physiol. 2011;155(3):1237–51.
Barnes WJ, Anderson CT. Acetyl bromide soluble lignin (ABSL) assay for total lignin quantification from plant biomass. Bio-Protoc. 2017;7:2149.
Li M, Pu Y, Ragauskas AJ. Current understanding of the correlation of lignin structure with biomass recalcitrance. Front Chem. 2016;4:45.
Albalasmeh AA, Berhe AA, Ghezzehei TA. A new method for rapid determination of carbohydrate and total carbon concentrations using UV spectrophotometry. Carbohyd Polym. 2013;97(2):253–61.
Zhang X, Gou M, Liu C-J. Arabidopsis Kelch repeat F-box proteins regulate phenylpropanoid biosynthesis via controlling the turnover of phenylalanine ammonia-lyase. Plant Cell. 2013;25(12):4994–5010.
Zhang X, Gou M, Guo C, Yang H, Liu C-J. Down-regulation of Kelch domain-containing F-box protein in Arabidopsis enhances the production of (poly) phenols and tolerance to ultraviolet radiation. Plant Physiol. 2015;167(2):337–50.
Rahikainen M, Alegre S, Trotta A, Pascual J, Kangasjärvi S. Trans-methylation reactions in plants: focus on the activated methyl cycle. Physiol Plant. 2018;162(2):162–76.
Ranocha P, McNeil SD, Ziemak MJ, Li C, Tarczynski MC, Hanson AD. The S-methylmethionine cycle in angiosperms: ubiquity, antiquity and activity. Plant J. 2001;25(5):575–84.
Baxter HL, Mazarei M, Labbe N, Kline LM, Cheng Q, Windham MT, Mann DG, Fu C, Ziebell A, Sykes RW. Two-year field analysis of reduced recalcitrance transgenic switchgrass. Plant Biotechnol J. 2014;12(7):914–24.
Tzin V, Galili G. New insights into the shikimate and aromatic amino acids biosynthesis pathways in plants. Mol Plant. 2010;3(6):956–72.
Herrmann KM. The shikimate pathway: early steps in the biosynthesis of aromatic compounds. Plant Cell. 1995;7(7):907.
Yin R, Messner B, Faus-Kessler T, Hoffmann T, Schwab W, Hajirezaei M-R, von Saint Paul V, Heller W, Schäffner AR. Feedback inhibition of the general phenylpropanoid and flavonol biosynthetic pathways upon a compromised flavonol-3-O-glycosylation. J Exp Bot. 2012;63(7):2465–78.
Blount JW, Korth KL, Masoud SA, Rasmussen S, Lamb C, Dixon RA. Altering expression of cinnamic acid 4-hydroxylase in transgenic plants provides evidence for a feedback loop at the entry point into the phenylpropanoid pathway. Plant Physiol. 2000;122(1):107–16.
Gaudinier A, Tang M, Kliebenstein DJ. Transcriptional networks governing plant metabolism. Curr Plant Biol. 2015;3:56–64.
Zhang X, Liu CJ. Multifaceted regulations of gateway enzyme phenylalanine ammonia-lyase in the biosynthesis of phenylpropanoids. Mol Plant. 2015;8(1):17–27.
Zhou R, Jackson L, Shadle G, Nakashima J, Temple S, Chen F, Dixon RA. Distinct cinnamoyl CoA reductases involved in parallel routes to lignin in Medicago truncatula. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2010;107(41):17803–8.
Derikvand MM, Sierra JB, Ruel K, Pollet B, Do C-T, Thévenin J, Buffard D, Jouanin L, Lapierre C. Redirection of the phenylpropanoid pathway to feruloyl malate in Arabidopsis mutants deficient for cinnamoyl-CoA reductase 1. Planta. 2008;227(5):943–56.
Leple J-C, Dauwe R, Morreel K, Storme V, Lapierre C, Pollet B, Naumann A, Kang K-Y, Kim H, Ruel K. Downregulation of cinnamoyl-coenzyme A reductase in poplar: multiple-level phenotyping reveals effects on cell wall polymer metabolism and structure. Plant Cell. 2007;19(11):3669–91.
Fu C, Mielenz JR, Xiao X, Ge Y, Hamilton CY, Rodriguez M, Chen F, Foston M, Ragauskas A, Bouton J, et al. Genetic manipulation of lignin reduces recalcitrance and improves ethanol production from switchgrass. Proc Natl Acad Sci. 2011;108(9):3803–8.
Yamauchi K, Yasuda S, Fukushima K. Evidence for the biosynthetic pathway from sinapic acid to syringyl lignin using labeled sinapic acid with stable isotope at both methoxy groups in Robinia pseudoacacia and Nerium indicum. J Agric Food Chem. 2002;50(11):3222–7.
Van Acker R, Déjardin A, Desmet S, Hoengenaert L, Vanholme R, Morreel K, Laurans F, Kim H, Santoro N, Foster C. Different routes for conifer and sinapaldehyde and higher saccharification upon deficiency in the dehydrogenase CAD1. Plant Physiol. 2017;175(3):1018–39.
Hazra S, Chattopadhyay S. An overview of lignans with special reference to podophyllotoxin, a cytotoxic lignan. Chem Biol Lett. 2016;3(1):1–8.
Jin H, Cominelli E, Bailey P, Parr A, Mehrtens F, Jones J, Tonelli C, Weisshaar B, Martin C. Transcriptional repression by AtMYB4 controls production of UV-protecting sunscreens in Arabidopsis. EMBO J. 2000;19(22):6150–61.
Berthet S, Demont-Caulet N, Pollet B, Bidzinski P, Cézard L, Le Bris P, Borrega N, Hervé J, Blondet E, Balzergue S. Disruption of LACCASE4 and 17 results in tissue-specific alterations to lignification of Arabidopsis thaliana stems. Plant Cell. 2011;23(3):1124–37.
Zhao Q, Nakashima J, Chen F, Yin Y, Fu C, Yun J, Shao H, Wang X, Wang Z-Y, Dixon RA. Laccase is necessary and nonredundant with peroxidase for lignin polymerization during vascular development in Arabidopsis. Plant Cell. 2013;25(10):3976–87.
Fernández-Pérez F, Vivar T, Pomar F, Pedreño MA, Novo-Uzal E. Peroxidase 4 is involved in syringyl lignin formation in Arabidopsis thaliana. J Plant Physiol. 2015;175:86–94.
Bryan AC, Jawdy S, Gunter L, Gjersing E, Sykes R, Hinchee MA, Winkeler KA, Collins CM, Engle N, Tschaplinski TJ. Knockdown of a laccase in Populus deltoides confers altered cell wall chemistry and increased sugar release. Plant Biotechnol J. 2016;14(10):2010–20.
Lin C-Y, Li Q, Tunlaya-Anukit S, Shi R, Sun Y-H, Wang JP, Liu J, Loziuk P, Edmunds CW, Miller ZD. A cell wall-bound anionic peroxidase, PtrPO21, is involved in lignin polymerization in Populus trichocarpa. Tree Genet Genomes. 2016;12(2):22.
Weigel D, Glazebrook J. Arabidopsis: a laboratory manual. Cold Spring Harbor: Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press; 2002.
Yang J, Worley E, Udvardi M. A NAP-AAO3 regulatory module promotes chlorophyll degradation via ABA biosynthesis in Arabidopsis leaves. Plant Cell. 2014;26(12):4862–74.
Dozmorov I, Centola M. An associative analysis of gene expression array data. Bioinformatics. 2003;19(2):204–11.
Shannon P, Markiel A, Ozier O, Baliga NS, Wang JT, Ramage D, Amin N, Schwikowski B, Ideker T. Cytoscape: a software environment for integrated models of biomolecular interaction networks. Genome Res. 2003;13(11):2498–504.
Hatfield RD, Grabber J, Ralph J, Brei K. Using the acetyl bromide assay to determine lignin concentrations in herbaceous plants: some cautionary notes. J Agric Food Chem. 1999;47:628–32.
Chen F, Srinivasa Reddy MS, Temple S, Jackson L, Shadle G, Dixon RA. Multi-site genetic modulation of monolignol biosynthesis suggests new routes for formation of syringyl lignin and wall-bound ferulic acid in alfalfa (Medicago sativa L.). Plant J. 2006;48(1):113–24.
Lapierre C, Pollet B, Rolando C. New insights into the molecular architecture of hardwood lignins by chemical degradative methods. Res Chem Intermed. 1995;21(3–5):397.
Nielsen SS. Phenol-sulfuric acid method for total carbohydrates. Food analysis laboratory manual. Berlin: Springer; 2010. p. 47–53.
Pu Y, Chen F, Ziebell A, Davison BH, Ragauskas AJ. NMR characterization of C3H and HCT down-regulated alfalfa lignin. BioEnergy Res. 2009;2(4):198.
Hu K, Westler WM, Markley JL. Simultaneous quantification and identification of individual chemicals in metabolite mixtures by two-dimensional extrapolated time-zero 1H–13C HSQC (HSQC0). J Am Chem Soc. 2011;133(6):1662–5.
da Costa RM, Pattathil S, Avci U, Lee SJ, Hazen SP, Winters A, Hahn MG, Bosch M. A cell wall reference pro for Miscanthus bioenergy crops highlights compositional and structural variations associated with development and organ origin. New Phytol. 2017;213(4):1710–25.
Shen H, Poovaiah CR, Ziebell A, Tschaplinski TJ, Pattathil S, Gjersing E, Engle NL, Katahira R, Pu Y, Sykes R. Enhanced characteristics of genetically modified switchgrass (Panicum virgatum L.) for high biofuel production. Biotechnology for Biofuels. 2013;6(1):71.
Pattathil S, Saffold T, Gallego-Giraldo L, O’Neill M, York WS, Dixon RA, Hahn MG. Changes in cell wall carbohydrate extractability are correlated with reduced recalcitrance of HCT downregulated alfalfa biomass. Ind Biotechnol. 2012;8(4):217–21.
Tschaplinski TJ, Standaert RF, Engle NL, Martin MZ, Sangha AK, Parks JM, Smith JC, Samuel R, Jiang N, Pu Y. Down-regulation of the caffeic acid O-methyltransferase gene in switchgrass reveals a novel monolignol analog. Biotechnol Biofuels. 2012;5(1):71.
Cossins EA, Chen L. Folates and one-carbon metabolism in plants and fungi. Phytochemistry. 1997;45(3):437–52.
Hanson AD, Gregory JF III. Folate biosynthesis, turnover, and transport in plants. Annu Rev Plant Biol. 2011;62:105–25.
Collakova E, Goyer A, Naponelli V, Krassovskaya I, Gregory JF, Hanson AD, Shachar-Hill Y. Arabidopsis 10-formyl tetrahydrofolate deformylases are essential for photorespiration. Plant Cell. 2008;20(7):1818–32.
Tzin V, Galili G. The biosynthetic pathways for shikimate and aromatic amino acids in Arabidopsis thaliana. Arabidopsis Book. 2010;8:e0132.
Tohge T, Watanabe M, Hoefgen R, Fernie AR. Shikimate and phenylalanine biosynthesis in the green lineage. Front Plant Sci. 2013;4:62.
Rinaldi R, Jastrzebski R, Clough MT, Ralph J, Kennema M, Bruijnincx PC, Weckhuysen BM. Paving the way for lignin valorisation: recent advances in bioengineering, biorefining and catalysis. Angew Chem Int Ed. 2016;55(29):8164–215.
HX, EBB, and YT: conceived the experiments and drafted the manuscript. HX, ACS, NH, and GL: contributed to plant material generation, conducted various molecular lab works, and contributed to manuscript drafting. NLE and TJT: conducted the metabolites profiling work and contributed to manuscript drafting. SV, SP, and MGH: conducted glycome profiling work and contributed to manuscript drafting. CGY, YP, and AJR: conducted whole cell-wall NMR analysis and contributed to manuscript drafting. HX, JB, ML, RSN, and RAD contributed to lignin analysis work and manuscript drafting. LS contributed to data analysis and manuscript drafting. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
The authors thank Stacy Allen at the Genomics Core of the Noble Research Institute for microarray data generation and Dr. Sanja Roje at Washington State University for critical reading of the manuscript.
This manuscript has been authored by UT-Battelle, LLC, under contract DE-AC05-00OR22725 with the US Department of Energy (DOE). The US government and the publisher, by accepting the article for publication, acknowledges that the US government retains a non-exclusive, paid-up, irrevocable, worldwide license to publish or reproduce the published form of this manuscript, or allow others to do so, for US government purposes. DOE will provide public access to these results of federally sponsored research in accordance with the DOE Public Access Plan (http://energy.gov/downloads/doe-public-access-plan).
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
The microarray data generated during the current study are available in ArrayExpress with accession number E-MTAB-7536 (http://www.ebi.ac.uk/arrayexpress/experiments/E-MTAB-7536).
Consent for publication
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The generation of the CCRC series of plant cell-wall glycan-directed monoclonal antibodies used in this work was supported by the National Science Foundation Plant Genome Research Program (DBI-0421683 and IOS-0923992). This work was funded by Noble Research Institute as well as the BioEnergy Science Center (BESC) and The Center for Bioenergy Innovation (CBI), US Department of Energy (DOE) Bioenergy Research Centers supported by the Office of Biological and Environmental Research in the DOE Office of Science. Oak Ridge National Laboratory is managed by UT-Battelle, LLC under Contract DE-AC05-00OR22725 with the US DOE. The views and opinions of the authors expressed herein do not necessarily state or reflect those of the United States government or any agency thereof. Neither the United States government nor any agency thereof, nor any of their employees, makes any warranty, expressed or implied, or assumes any legal liability or responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of any information, apparatus, product, or process disclosed, or represents that its use would not infringe privately owned rights.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Additional file 1: Table S1. Primers used for genotyping and gene expression analysis by RT-PCR and QRT-PCR.
Additional file 2: Fig. S1. The phenotype of 9-day-old seedlings of WT, fpgs1, ccoaomt1 and fpgs1ccoaomt1 plants. Similar to fpgs1 single mutants, fpgs1ccoaomt1double mutants had short roots during early development.
Additional file 3: Table S2. Whole cell wall NMR analysis of 6-week-old stems of WT, fpgs1, ccoaomt1 and fpgs1ccoaomt1 plants. Note. Linkages = (β-O-4) + (β–β) + (β-5) *: significantly different than wild type according to one-way ANOVA analysis (P ≤ 0.05). **Both acetyl and methoxyl content were estimated from whole cell wall components in the AIR. To obtain changes in content between genotypes in relation to lignin, values in each sample were normalized against their own lignin using “acetyl (or methoxyl) peak area/total lignin subunits (S + G+H)”. The f1-1, f1-2 and f1-3 are three biological replicates for fpgs1; the cc1-1, 2, 3 are three biological replicates for ccoaomt1; the f1cc1-1, 2, 3 are three biological replicates for fpgs1ccoaomt1.
Additional file 4: Fig S2. Heatmap of glycome profiling analysis of stem extracts from 6-week-old stem of WT, fpgs1, ccoaomt1 and fpgs1ccoaomt1 plants. AIR was processed through six different extraction conditions with increasing harshness. Only epitopes of significantly different antibody detection signals in pairwise comparisons among these four genotypes were included in this heatmap (Student’s t-test of P-value ≤ 0.05). Color represent the signal level of different monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) bound with non-cellulosic cell wall epitopes. The name of the antibodies and their recognized non-cellulosic carbohydrate epitope types are presented on the right side of the heat map.
Additional file 5: Fig. S3. The heatmap of log2 ratio of metabolites from 6-week-old stem of fpgs1, ccoaomt1 and fpgs1ccoaomt1 compared with WT. More than 100 peaks were detected in WT, fpgs1, ccoaomt1 and fpgs1ccoaomt1, and 77 were assigned to known chemical structures. The identified compounds were arranged based on their categories, and their relative level changes in fpgs1, ccoaomt1 and fpgs1ccoaomt1 compared to WT were visualized as a heatmap by software MeV. Compound 2-O-feruloyl-malic acid was not detected in WT and fpgs1, so it is not shown on the heatmap. Abbreviations: f1- fpgs1, cc1- ccoaomt1, f1cc1 - fpgs1ccoaomt1. Number positioned in front of tentatively identified metabolites are the retention time (RT; min) and key mass-to-charge (m/z) ratios.
Additional file 6: Table S3. Differentially-accumulated metabolites in 6-week-old stems of WT, fpgs1 (f1), ccoaomt1 (cc1) and fpgs1ccoaomt1 (f1cc1) plants. Selection threshold for significant metabolites (marked with *, up in red, down in blue) is P < 0.05 (Student’s t-test). Metabolite concentration (ug/g fresh weight; sorbitol equivalents). The retention time (RT; min) and key mass-to-charge (m/z) ratios are positioned in front of tentatively identified metabolites.
Additional file 7: Fig. S4. Presentation of differentially expressed genes in the 6-week-old Arabidopsis stems of fpgs1, ccoaomt1 and fpgs1ccoaomt1 plants compared with WT. Genes with two fold changes in expression levels in fpgs1, ccoaomt1 or fpgs1ccoaomt1, compared with WT, were included in the image. Red - upregulated genes; Blue - downregulated genes. Yellow - each mutants, square - genes in phenylpropanoid/lignin/glucosinolate pathway (At1g80820-AtCCR2; At1g20510-OPCL1; At2g29130-AtLAC2; At1g21110-IGMT3; At1g21120-IGMT2; At4g34050-CCoAOMT1; At1g21130-IGMT4); Triangle - one carbon pathway genes (At5g05980-FPGS1). Lines show the relationship of genes among the mutants.
Additional file 8: Table S4. Microarray analysis representing 6-week-old stems of WT, fpgs1, ccoaomt1 and fpgs1ccoaomt1 plants.
Additional file 9: Fig. S5. Schematic representation of shikimate pathway, aromatic amino acids (AAA) pathway, and lignin pathway association with C1 metabolism. Adapted from the following papers [13, 17, 37, 43, 93,94,95,96,97,98]. Solid Arrows represent enzymatic reactions together with the name of the enzyme that catalyzes the associated reaction. Empty circles represent the products of the enzymatic reactions along with the products’ names nearby. Dotted arrows represent multiple enzymatic reactions. Red dotted rectangles represent shikimate pathways. Amber dotted rectangles represent aromatic amino acids (AAA) pathways. Green dotted rectangles represent lignin pathways. Purple dotted rectangles represent C1 metabolism. CM: chorismatemutase; PAT: prephenate aminotransferase; ADT: arogenatedehydratase; PAL: phenylalanine ammonia-lyase; C4H: cinnamate-4-hydroxylase; 4CL: 4-coumarateCoAligase; CCR: cinnamoyl-CoA reductase; CAD: cinnamyl alcohol dehydrogenase; C3H: p-Coumarate 3-hydroxylase; HCT: folylpolyglutamate synthase; C3′H: p-coumaroyl quinate/shikimate 3′-hydroxylase, CSE: 5,10-methylene tetrahydrofolate polyglutamates; COMT: caffeic acid O-methyl transferase; CCoAOMT: caffeoyl-CoA O-methyltransferase; F5H: ferulate 5-hydroxylase; CAD: cinnamyl alcohol dehydrogenase; SGT: sinapate:UDP-glucose glucosyltransferase; SMT: sinapoylglucose:malate sinapoyltransferase; ADC: amino deoxychorismate; ADCL: amino deoxychorismate (ADC) lyase; ADCS: amino deoxychorismate (ADC) synthase; pABA: para-aminobenzoic acid; DHPS: dihydropteroate (DHP) synthase; DHFS: dihydrofolate (DHF) synthase; DHF-Glu1: dihydrofolate with one glutamate; DHFR: dihydrofolate (DHF) reductase; THF-Glu1: tetrahydrofolate with one glutamate; FPGS: folylpolyglutamate synthase; THF-Glun: tetrahydrofolate polyglutamates; SHMT: serine hydroxymethyl transferase; CH2-THF-Glun: 5,10-methylene tetrahydrofolate polyglutamates; DHC: 5,10-methylene tetrahydrofolate dehydrogenase/5,10-methenyl THF cyclohydrolase; 10-CHO-THF-Glun: 10-methenyl tetrahydrofolate polyglutamates; FTHS: 10-formyltetrahydrofolate synthetase; MTHFR: methylene tetrahydrofolate reductase; CH3-THF-Glun: 5-methyl tetrahydrofolate polyglutamates; MS: methionine synthase; SAMS: S-adenosylmethionine synthetase; SAM: S-Adenosyl methionine (AdoMet); SAMMT: S-adenosylmethionine methyltransferase; SAHH: S-adenosylhomocysteine hydrolase.
About this article
- folylpolyglutamate synthetase1
- caffeoyl-CoA 3-O-methyltransferase1
- Glycome profiling
- Metabolite profiling
- Phenylpropanoid pathway